Inspiron 1090 Hard Drive Compatibility

Hi Community, I have an Inspiron 1090 that has a busted HDD. 

It originally had a HGST Z7K320-320 which I have replaced with a HGST Z7K500-320. I installed the software (32 Home Premium) on a computer with the Z7K500 connected as the Inspiron lacks a disc drive, which worked fine, everything installed and updated.

I then attempted to boot the Inspiron with the Z7K500 HDD with 32 bit Home Premium installed, however after the Dell Loading screen the computer bluescreens for a fraction of a second and then reboots.

So my main question is why is this doing this, is the HDD incompatible or have I missed a step here?

Thanks in advance!