UNSOLVED

ujopeto

updated

8 years ago

U

ujopeto

10 Posts

0

10976

June 13th, 2016 14:00

Inspiron 7559 with i7 Linux fan control problem

Hello.

I have Dell Inspiron 7559 with i7 cpu. I've noticed problems with fan control on Linux (I've tried many distros and kernels from 4.4 to 4.6.2, run it on nvidia or intel gpu only, but the problem is the same). Once the fans are started to spin, they are spinning forever even when the system is cooled down (cpu and GPU has about +30C for more than hour). On the same machine on Windows 10, fans are switched off when the system is cooled down. I've tried to config it using pwmconfig which could stop and speed up the fans during the configuration, but after saving config to /etc/fancontrol it did not help at all and fans are still spinning. I've found that setting acpi_osi=(Windows||Linux||!Wiindows 2012) on grub might help, but after various attempts and settings it did not help at all. Could you please anybody help me to configure this fancontrol or help me to setup it with behavior as like as on Windows 10 is or make a patch for kernel/driver or whatever... I need Linux (not in VM) for my work and it is really disturbing once the fans are started to spin even at the speed at 2k rpm and I need to be focused on my work. Thank you.

Here is the screenshot of psensor after 2hours of idle system.

  • eggbert74

    1 Rookie

    15 Posts

    6213

    0

    Posted July 12th, 2016 21:00

    Hi,

    I have the same issue under Linux with the Inspiron 7559.  Have you ever found a solution?  I've seen a few reports about spotty fan control issues with this laptop...

    A few observations I have:

    1. Fans appear to work correctly under Windoze 10.

    2. Under Linux fans run at low speed even when the CPU is cool.

    3. Fans under Linux will eventually shut off if I pop the bottom off the laptop and blow cool air onto the mother board.  Looking at lm-sensors, it seems like they shut off when the SODIMM temp gets below 39c. CPU/GPU temp seems to be irrelevant.

  • ujopeto

    10 Posts

    6213

    0

    Posted July 13th, 2016 00:00

    Hello,

    the only "working" workaround (I wouldn't call it solution as no one from Dell responded for this problem anywhere) I've found for this is:

    install i8kutils

    then in terminal:

    sudo gedit /etc/i8kmon.conf

    paste this:

    # Run as daemon, override with --daemon option

    set config(daemon)      0

    # Automatic fan control, override with --auto option

    set config(auto)        1

    # Report status on stdout, override with --verbose option

    set config(verbose) 1

    # Status check timeout (seconds), override with --timeout option

    set config(timeout) 20

    # For computer with 2 fans, use a variant of this instead:

    # Temperature thresholds: {fan_speeds low_ac high_ac low_batt high_batt}

    set config(0) { {0 0}  -1  55  -1  55}

    set config(1) { {1 1}  36  60  36  60}

    set config(2) { {1 1}  52  70  52  70}

    set config(3) { {2 2}  65  78  65  78}

    set config(4) { {2 2}  75 128  75 128}

    # end of file

    and then run:

    sudo /etc/init.d/i8kmon restart


    You can play with temps :)

    Anyway it would be good if ANYONE from Dell replies for this as they should support Linux. Still, I do not know if this is the problem of kernel/any driver/BIOS or how the heck the fans are/should be managed on Linux.

  • ujopeto

    10 Posts

    6213

    0

    Posted July 13th, 2016 00:00

    see my post

  • eggbert74

    1 Rookie

    15 Posts

    6213

    0

    Posted July 13th, 2016 10:00

    Thanks. I've actually tried i8kutils before, but I don't trust it.  I think something might be actually heating up on this laptop under Linux.   (I'm the guy on ubuntuforums.org where this solution was posted)  

    Unfortunately, I doubt anyone from Dell is going to help us.  Dell support seems clueless about pretty much everything.  Our best bet would be to file bugs with Ubuntu and/or the Linux kernel.

    https://bugs.launchpad.net/

    https://bugzilla.kernel.org/

    Then if all users who experience fan issues on this laptop can chime in on the bug reports, it actually might get fixed.  Still a long shot, but I don't know what else to try at this point.

  • eggbert74

    1 Rookie

    15 Posts

    6213

    0

    Posted July 13th, 2016 14:00

    Thanks.  I've actually played around with i8kutils, but I don't trust it on this laptop.  I still kind of think something is heating up under Linux.   I'm actually the guy in the thread over on Ubuntu Forums where this solution was suggested.

    I doubt anyone from Dell will help us.  Dell support seems clueless about pretty much everything.  I think our best bet would be to file bug reports with Ubuntu and/or the Linux kernel.

  • ujopeto

    10 Posts

    6213

    0

    Posted July 13th, 2016 14:00

    Hello, I did that couple weeks ago already

    answers.launchpad.net/.../293866

    Seems like no one is interested about this topic and people just giving their hands away from this problem.

    I'm starting to regret buying Dell laptop.  :(

  • eggbert74

    1 Rookie

    15 Posts

    6213

    0

    Posted July 13th, 2016 15:00

    I know what you mean.  I hate the 7559.  Worst Linux experience ever... but I'm stuck with it now.

    Anyway, I think answers.launchpad.net is different than bugs.launchpad.net.  I think the later is actually where you file bugs.  I will see if I can file a bug report later when I get some free time, and then maybe we can get others with the fan issue to chime in on it.  They seem to take it seriously when multiple users have the same bug.    

  • eggbert74

    1 Rookie

    15 Posts

    6212

    2

    Posted July 13th, 2016 17:00

    I've filed a bug report on ubuntu launch pad about this.

    bugs.launchpad.net/.../1602888

    Posting it here in case anyone else reading this might want to click on "this bug affects me" or chime in on it, since Dell will give us no help on this.  

  • Wyjec

    1 Message

    6212

    0

    Posted August 13th, 2016 04:00

    Hi everybody. I can confirm that problem is affecting my 7720SE. The only thing it worked for me is to disable BIOS fan management. Its preety hard to do because Dell has no advanced BIOS options while booting. After that i8kultis is not fighting with BIOS settings. There is no more full-low speed fan dance all the time.

  • 2084

    1

    Posted October 27th, 2016 11:00

    I'd like to bring this back the front and see if anybody else has suggestions.  Nothing has worked and the fans will run forever under any version of Linux.  We need a Dell engineer to look at this or some support person.