lsc9x
1 Copper

"Final" Dell XPS 420 Video Card Upgrade Question(s)

Hi folks!

I am looking at helping a friend upgrade his Dell XPS 420 to the max it can handle and have some questions.

His system is the XPS 420 with a 375 watt power supply, the Core 2 Q6600 2.4ghz processor (it might be 2.6...), 4GB of system RAM and the ATI 2600XT 256MB video card.  The system is running Windows 7 Ultimate, 64bit edition and it runs without a hitch.  It has a PCIs 2.0 x16 video card slot.

It's not a bad system, all things considered.  I already know we can upgrade the RAM to 8GB, no problem.

Obviously the issue with upgrading his system is: 

- The video card (what card, will it work with system, will it work with slot, will it work with power supply)

- The power supply itself (maybe)

After looking at the "Dell recommended" hardware, they want $159 for an ATI Radeon 4350 HD which is a huge amount of money for a card that is arguably only one step about the 2600 XT and at least 3 year old technology.  The other cards offered are even less of an upgrade.

After doing a lot of research, I found that the newer ATI cards are a lot less money, but most of them require a PCIe 2.1 x16 slot.  I know that PCIe 2.1 cards are SUPPOSED to work in PCIe 2.0 slots, but knowing Dell as an OEM, my fear is that they have done something to the port to only work with their hardware.  So, I decided to look at PCIe 2.0 cards, the majority of which are Nvidia GeForce cards.

Comparing the ATI 4850 HD card with 512MB of RAM (which is what I have on my computer), and the system requirements for RAGE and Crysis 2 (both of which run very well on my system) the card I am looking at is either the Geforce 9800GTX or the Geforce GTS 250, which are recommended for RAGE.

Those video cards should fit into the tower case (I have to look at dimensions for the GTS 250), and they should be compatible with the PCIe 2.0 slot since that's what they are rated for.

Having said that, the power supply requirements (or recommendations) for the GTS 250 is 400 watts.  Since the XPS 420 only has a 375 watt power supply, I was looking at upgrading that with a Corsair 500 watt power supply, but only if really needed.

OK, so my questions:

1) Do you think the Geforce GTS 250 card will work with this system?

2) If I upgrade the power supply to a Corsair 500 watt, is this going to fry anything in the system?  Will it be compatible with the mainboard?

My friend just doesn't have the money to buy a new computer system, and it would be a waste of money to get an ATI 4350 HD card for $160 bucks when we card get a card several generations higher with a much better power supply for roughly the same amount of money.

This, obviously, will be the "last gasp" for the XPS 420 system.  Any further upgrades will be highly unlikely.

Opinions?  Suggestions?

Thanks!

0 Kudos
8 Krypton

Re: "Final" Dell XPS 420 Video Card Upgrade Question(s)

You are not limited to buying Dell parts and it would be better to buy 3dr party parts. The system is most likely out of warranty so there will be nothing to worry about on that end. While Dell does use some custom setting there is nothing related to your upgrades that will be of issue. The 250 is a good card  and will fit nicely in the system. Upgrading the ram to 4 or 8 gigs will also give the system a performance boost.

 Home Built Sandy Bridge P8P67 i7 2600k @ 4.5 GHz 8gigs GSkill Ripjaws. Corsair 800D Case and AX1200 Ps X-Fi Titanium Fatal1ty pro PCIe Sound Card
Dell Studio XPS 1645  Window 10 Pro

Forum member since 2003

0 Kudos
8 Krypton

Re: "Final" Dell XPS 420 Video Card Upgrade Question(s)

Both the 9800 GTX and GTS 250 are old cards.  If you are looking for something in this range, go with the GTS 450.  Others have used the GTS 450 on their 375 watt Dell power supplies.  The ATI card in this range would be the HD 5770 or HD 6770 (same with just a name change).  The GTS 450 will use less power than the older 9800 GTX or GTS 250.  

$160 for an HD 4350 is pretty crazy.  The 2600XT is actually a much better card.  

0 Kudos
lsc9x
1 Copper

Re: "Final" Dell XPS 420 Video Card Upgrade Question(s)

That would be a great solution if I didn't need to mess with the power!  Thanks!

0 Kudos
lsc9x
1 Copper

Re: "Final" Dell XPS 420 Video Card Upgrade Question(s)

Thank you.  I'll take that note along with the next guy's.  😃

0 Kudos