The issue was WavesMaxx audio. As jimco stated, WavesMaxx has a pop-up that will ask which kind of device you are using. Without noticing, I had the "Headphones" option checked, being the slash inbetween "Headphones" and "Headset" and actual option divider. I thought it was a "hybrid-option" kind of thing. You have to actually click the text that reads "Headset", and when it turns blue, you've got your device selected. Thanks to jimco for the help.