I did not think I had a problem, I have been playing Battlefield 1 without problem or noticing any issues for the last 5 days. The machine does sound like a vacuum cleaner, but I thought that was maybe just how noisy the machine is.
Yesterday however the machine shutdown while playing Assassins Creed Syndicate (on ultra). I checked and the windows log reports "The system was shut down due to a critical thermal event." So I then hit google and found out there could be a problem in general. I did the dell stress test and then talked with dell support today. They claim I do not have a problem and that temps of 98 degrees while playing battlefield 1 is normal.
I put battlefield 1 in windows mode while chatting to the guy from Dell. And took a photo of the temps to show him. His words were, "Das ist normal würde ich sagen" (That is normal, to me).
I have further ii´nvestigated this Issue. My CPU (6820) goes up to 12% into thermal throtteling.
The tool i used to test was AIDA64, the same the shared tests reffer to. On BIOS 1.02 the System forced to Shutdown, because of an thermal iussue.
On BIOS 1.06 i have performance degedradtion and throtteling around 6-12% on my System.
It would be helpful if an Dell repesentative could tell us more. I actually think my device has two faults, the display bleed issue and the thermal problem,
Just testet with default settings on the BIOS. The systems stands on an normal table and has nothing airflow blocking around itself. DELL i think there is an serious Problem ....
CPU & GPU
Update - 30 Min of Witcher 3 1.31 with all Add Ons:
I already talked to a guy from tech support he claimed:
11/18/2016 04:03:17PM
Mittel (JK): "Es geht nur darum, ob er noch abschaltet"
That just cant be true. There is a huge difference in temps between core 0 and core 3, and the system is reported as running at 60 by the media. Something is not right.
So I just finished chatting with the Dell Support people. They do not think that there is a problem with the laptop and the 16 degree difference in core temps is fine...
Here you go, the full result of my chat...
11/21/2016 07:52:56AM Keith Ball: "I am not happy with the heat of my laptop. Having read online a couple of reviews that claim their aw 15r3 is able to game at 60 degrees, I think there is something not right with mine." 11/21/2016 07:53:07AM Keith Ball: "www.tomshardware.com/.../alienware-15-r3-gaming-laptop,4796-4.html" 11/21/2016 07:53:16AM Keith Ball: "www.mobiletechreview.com/.../Alienware-15-R3.htm" 11/21/2016 07:53:26AM Mittel (JK): "Does the system switchoff again?" 11/21/2016 07:54:21AM Keith Ball: "I have not hit that problem since the bios update, but I am getting thermal throttling events all the time." 11/21/2016 07:54:45AM Keith Ball: "I also have a core temp difference of 16 degrees" 11/21/2016 07:54:47AM Keith Ball: "https://photos.google.com/photo/AF1QipNtDPNP3ZBknPAOFTxqP0rAMOAVyMqth3gSCNmD" 11/21/2016 07:55:20AM Mittel (JK): "Thats normaly if you stress the system with games" 11/21/2016 07:55:37AM Keith Ball: "90+ is not normal and will kill the laptop." 11/21/2016 07:55:39AM Mittel (JK): "Close the application that showing the temperature" 11/21/2016 07:55:41AM Keith Ball: "It is also not what is claimed." 11/21/2016 07:55:57AM Mittel (JK): "Now play" 11/21/2016 07:56:24AM Mittel (JK): "Thats a mobile system" 11/21/2016 07:56:49AM Keith Ball: "So you are claiming that this is normal?" 11/21/2016 07:57:13AM Mittel (JK): "Does the diagnostics showing any error-code?" 11/21/2016 07:57:24AM Mittel (JK): "Can you normaly play?" 11/21/2016 07:57:33AM Keith Ball: "The lifetime of the laptop will not last very long with those heat problems and it is underperforming." 11/21/2016 07:57:56AM Keith Ball: "I get jitters in game, when the Thermal Events occur." 11/21/2016 07:58:27AM Keith Ball: "The diagnostics show no errors." 11/21/2016 07:59:02AM Keith Ball: "So, you say that laptop is fine. ok. Who do I talk to about returning it, as I cant believe you think 90+ is ok." 11/21/2016 07:59:04AM Mittel (JK): "Than seems to be all OK." 11/21/2016 07:59:38AM Mittel (JK): "If you stress the system, then 90 degree is OK" 11/21/2016 08:00:26AM Keith Ball: "So how do you explain the core temp difference?" 11/21/2016 08:00:52AM Keith Ball: "One core running at 80, which I would accept as being stressed and the other 96?" 11/21/2016 08:02:00AM Mittel (JK): "different stress" 11/21/2016 08:02:29AM Keith Ball: "To me it seems like it needs to be repasted. And there heatsink is sitting incorrectly on the cpu." 11/21/2016 08:02:42AM Mittel (JK): "PLEASE CLOSE THE TEMPERATURE-SCREEN" 11/21/2016 08:05:02AM Keith Ball: "Who do I get in touch with to either get a second opinion on this? As I think it needs to be repaired, or how do I return the device?" 11/21/2016 08:06:49AM Mittel (JK): "The system is technical OK. We cant take back the system here in the techn. support" 11/21/2016 08:07:42AM Mittel (JK): "NO technical problem" 11/21/2016 08:07:45AM Keith Ball: "And you will not send someone to repaste and reseat the cpu?" 11/21/2016 08:07:54AM Mittel (JK): "NO" 11/21/2016 08:08:03AM Keith Ball: "ok, thanks." 11/21/2016 08:08:07AM Keith Ball: "Have a nice day." 11/21/2016 08:08:14AM Mittel (JK): "thanks"
I am apparently the proud owner of a perfectly fine and working AW15R3... I guess all I can do now is either manually repaste myself or return the damned thing. I just gave them a LOT of money for this thing.
Hi there, same Problem here. Just had a 40 Minutes phone call with technical support. First thing he did some tests and said that the differences between the cores are way to high and there should be a problem. Then he discussed the Problem with his boss and told me that everything is fine LOL.
It is "normal" that the CPU reaches temps close to 100°C WTF??? There is a Problem with the heatsink and they will not fix it. Other systems dont have this problem, so it is not the cpu, its is the paste, the heatsink and the gap between cpu and heatsink.
I am just thinking of sending my alien back. The rest of the system is nice and works fine, so i am not sure what to do now.
The_Jay_Kay
15 Beiträge
4800
1
Posted 19. November 2016 02:00
Maybe we meet at the Battlefield ;)
I will check the Temps these Days and will get u the infos from my system.
Update: see those temps - i think i have an temperature Issue :D
I had an Gigabyte P35X-v6 before, the Alienware 15 is not as noisy as u may think imho.
Regards
JK