UNSOLVED

Mentaur

updated

22 years ago

M

Mentaur

3 Posts

0

43080

November 17th, 2004 13:00

1905FP ghosting problems

Hi,
 
my new 1905FP arrived yesterday, and I proudly hooked it up to my GeForce 6800GT card via DVI and marvelled at the quality of the desktop picture. 
 
I then launched World of Warcraft - fabulous, until I moved the mouse.  Woah.  Blur city.  I checked the resolution was 1280x1024 but again, everything is fine until I move the mouse, then the picture just loses all definition and motion blurs.
 
HalfLife 2.  Staggeringly beautiful, again until I move the mouse.  Then everything just goes terribly blurry, with blacks especially leaving trails all over the screen.  Instant headache after 5mins of play.  This game has loads of details and contrast, but even so, it looks like an LCD reponse time of 200ms rather than 20ms.
 
Now I know this is only 20ms and not 16ms response time, but I never expected it to be this awful.  How can the extra 4ms suddenly make it great?  Under DVI you get little control, but I've pulled the brightness down to 0 which is about all I can do.  I've tried to force the GeForce to do 60Hz at 1280x1024 but the OSD always seems to report 75Hz as the refresh rate.  Could that be the issue? 
 
How can I force 60Hz under DVI?  I've gone to desktop properties and set 1280x1024 @ 60Hz but the OSD still reports it being 75Hz.
 
Is this just how it is with the 1905FP?  If so I want my money back as it is horrible.
 
Any advice gratefully received,
Thanks,
Nick
  • FrankPoole

    10 Posts

    283

    0

    Posted November 20th, 2004 23:00

    Hi Craig,

    Thanks for the link. One of the interesting things about this is that the white to black response time seems good. However, the white to dark blue (or whatever other color) seems TERRIBLE. I am talking like 40 - 50 ms terrible. I am wondering if they optimize the monitor response for full white to full black so that they can advertise good "full" range response times.

    Looks like Dell will be shipping me a new monitor, so hopefully this will sort things out.

    Thanks again for your help!

    Gabriel
  • VCraig

    2 Intern

    •

    2106 Posts

    283

    0

    Posted November 21st, 2004 01:00

    ...."I am wondering if they optimize the monitor response for full white to full black so that they can advertise good "full" range response times" ......

    I can't recall off-hand which one but I did read in a major computer mag comments to this effect. Whatever. Let's hope the replacement monitor works....because I have a new XPS GEN 3 system in transient as I write this that includes the 1905FP...

    OOPS.... just remembered after I posted - the review was for the 1901FP...sorry about that.....

     


    Message Edited by VCraig on 11-20-2004 10:11 PM

  • FrankPoole

    10 Posts

    283

    0

    Posted November 21st, 2004 05:00

    Well, good luck with the CRT. I don't really have room for another one, so I am going to have to hope that the new one works out better. Wish me luck

    Craig, good luck with yours as well. I hope you don't have any troubles.

    Gabriel
  • Jag-68

    1 Rookie

    •

    39 Posts

    283

    0

    Posted November 26th, 2004 18:00

    I didn't have any ghosting on my 1905FP until i booted up HL2, maxed out. It's a little noticeable when i'm moving, but overall not TOO bad.
  • Mentaur

    3 Posts

    283

    0

    Posted December 8th, 2004 20:00

    I'm afraid I never got a replacement.  Instead I bought a Dell 21inch CRT monitor (a badged trinitron) for £160 less from an internet website.  It is stunning, though obviously takes up a bit more room.  The ghosting problem was so bad on the 1905FP it is possible I had a bad one, as I can't believe any review would have missed it.  I decided that even a fixed unit was still not going to do my Nvidia 6800GT justice so saved so money and went for a CRT, figuring I would get a flat panel in a few more years when the technology has improved again.
  • Corx

    1 Message

    283

    0

    Posted December 8th, 2004 20:00

    Hello,

     

    I want to buy the Dell 1905 FP TFT cause it was tested very good in a german pc-magazin.

    Now I read about your problems with the "ghosting". Have you solved these problems? Has the ghosting gone? Was your TFT damaged?

     

    Thnx a lot!

     

    Corx

  • FrankPoole

    10 Posts

    283

    0

    Posted December 8th, 2004 21:00

    Unfortunately, I also had to select a different monitor. I ended up with a Samsung 712N 17" LCD. I have found it to be far superior to the 1905FP, although I (very slightly) miss the larger screen.

    I went through two of the 1905FP monitors and both of them had severe ghosting issues. I would strongly recommend a different choice. The 2001FP I use at work seems to be vasty superior.

    Although I was disappointed with Dell for advertising this monitor as having reduced ghosting, I would like to offer Kudos to Dell support for helping me sort everything out quickly.

    Message Edited by FrankPoole on 12-08-2004 05:21 PM

  • KingKruiser

    1 Message

    283

    0

    Posted December 9th, 2004 07:00

    I thought I was the only one! It has been over a month and I'm on the second monitor, still with horrible problems! This ghosting is rediculous, I am going to demand something else. I spent so much and yet it is such a bad monitor! What did you guys do? Help me out =)
  • ddeluca

    4 Posts

    283

    0

    Posted December 26th, 2004 18:00

    OK - I am a newbee but a techy at heart.... What is exactly ghosting on th 1905FP...
    I have this monitor and what just wondering if I am getting ghosting...
     
    Thanks,
  • 254

    0

    Posted January 25th, 2005 20:00

    Ghosting is when you move something quickly, and you can see a trail of it behind.
     
    It really gives a headache in a fast past 3d video game as if makes you feel like you're tripping on acid.
     
    The reason I'm posting is I just received my 1905FP and hooked it up last night (January 24, 2005) and it is HORRIBLE with ghosting.
     
    I'm sending it back.
     
    Probably get the 20" wide screen.
     
    Maybe it's a marketing ploy.
     
    Really dissappointed here.