UNSOLVED

gstick

updated

19 years ago

G

gstick

28 Posts

0

2496

December 12th, 2007 11:00

Virus Software

I have a Dimension 3000 with Windows XP Home Edition with Service Pack Two. My automatic update switch is ON. The computer came with McAfee Security Center. McAfee reports that I am "fully protected" but then seems to infer that their Internet Security Suite is needed (for more money). My Windows Firewall is ON I have the free versions of Ad-Aware and Spybot installed and run updates and scans weekly. However, a new issue of USAA magazine tells me that I should run Anti virus Software in addition to the anti-spyware software and the Firewall. I currently do not seem to have any problems. Do I need more software?
  • ky331

    5 Journeyman

    •

    15642 Posts

    •

    45090 Points

    726

    0

    Posted December 12th, 2007 13:00

    You want to run:

    exactly ONE resident (=continually running in real-time) anti-virus program

    exactly ONE software firewall

    ONE(*) resident anti-spyware program.

    It's unclear which McAfee product you're currently running, if it's suggesting to you that you need their Internet Security suite [which typically includes all three of the above aspects].   Presumably, you have at least their anti-virus???

    Ad-Aware and Spybot are primarily on-demand scanners.   They are not offering resident protection, unless you've enabled Spybot's TeaTimer feature.

     

    (*) While many people ("the conventional wisdom" ) insist that you run exactly one resident anti-spyware program, it seems that some combinations in fact work well together.   for example, I run spyBot's TeaTimer in addition to Windows Defender.   So I think there's some room for "flex" (i.e., experimentation) here.



    Message Edited by ky331 on 12-12-2007 10:14 AM
  • gstick

    28 Posts

    726

    0

    Posted January 26th, 2008 18:00

    I got distracted by another matter in December.

    I have McAfee PC Protection Plus. I believe that this product does provide virus protection. The system scans on a regular basis.

    The McAfee terminology confuses me. Their marketing game, I believe, could have you adding features indefinitely.

    Assuming I have resident virus protection (McAfee PC Protection Plus)
    and one firewall (Windows)then I seem to need
    one resident anti-spyware program?

    Thanks for your help.
  • Bugbatter

    4 Apprentice

    •

    20487 Posts

    726

    0

    Posted January 26th, 2008 19:00

    According to this, it appears that your McAfee software includes anti-spyware and does everything but cook dinner and do laundry for you:

    http://us.mcafee.com/root/package.asp?pkgid=270
  • gstick

    28 Posts

    726

    0

    Posted January 28th, 2008 11:00

    Yet when I have run Ad-Aware scans I come up with "critical items" which they recommend deleting?

    McAfee Security Center tells me that I need "Identity Protection" and "Spam Protection." Clicking on these takes me to a "Security Suite" page that I can add for more money?

    Do I believe Ad-Aware of McAfee?

    McAfee's product information is loaded with terminology that seems to change from one presentation to the next. It is difficult to understand what you have and what you need.
  • ky331

    5 Journeyman

    •

    15642 Posts

    •

    45090 Points

    726

    0

    Posted January 28th, 2008 12:00

    1) different programs, such as ad-aware and mcafee, use different databases.   that's why one may pick-up-on things the other one "misses".   that's also why we strongly advocate you run two or more anti-malware scanners.
     
    2) TRACKING COOKIES should NOT be viewed as " CRITICAL" items, even if an anti-spyware program classifies them as such.
    Is ad-aware finding any "critical" items, OTHER THAN tracking cookies?
     
    3) which ad-aware are you running?:   Ad-Aware SE personal is now considered obsolete... they stopped updating it as of the end of 2007.
    Ad-Aware 2007 is a current program, but we're not happy with it.
  • ky331

    5 Journeyman

    •

    15642 Posts

    •

    45090 Points

    726

    0

    Posted January 28th, 2008 13:00

    no, nothing to do with Kentucky.
     
    there's plenty of good, quality programs that are free.    
    we are currently recommending SuperAntiSpyware [get the Free Version for Home Users] http://www.superantispyware.com/
    After downloading & installing, be sure to check for updates first, and then run the COMPLETE scan.
     
    "malware" is a more general term (for BAD-stuff)... it includes "adware" (unwanted advertisements), "spyware" (programs that can "spy" on what you're doing), and just about any other "ugly" classification that might be applied.   ["foistware", "PUPS", and the like]
     
    i believe ad-aware's "negligible" items are the MRU's ( Most Recently Used objects).    these pose absolutely no problems if there's only one user on a personal computer.   if several people share a machine (home/personal or at work), you can  decide for yourself if these are significant or not, since other users can use these to see what programs you've been running recently, the file's you've opened recently, the websites you've accessed recently, &etc.
     
    what type of problems does spybot find (aside from cookies)??
     
     


    Message Edited by ky331 on 01-28-2008 11:00 AM
  • gstick

    28 Posts

    726

    0

    Posted January 28th, 2008 13:00

    Thanks ky(Kentucky?). Ad-Aware also reports "negligible" items (cookies?). I don't really know what these are but have been deleting them.

    From your earlier advice I also run Spy-bot which, on a weekly basis, comes up with about 30 "problems" which they delete for me.

    Since I'm just starting to take this topic more seriously I am confused by terminology. You refer to malware but Spybot, Ad-Aware and McAfee all use different terms.

    I understand about more than one program. I will continue to run Spybot. But I've been working on the assumption that Spybot and Ad-Aware are chasing different bad guys or, at least, have different data bases. Is this true and, if so, can you recommend a replacement for Ad-Aware?

    So far, other than McAfee, I have been running free stuff. Will this have to change?