UNSOLVED

Maui Wowie

updated

19 years ago

MW

Maui Wowie

1 Rookie

117 Posts

0

10989

January 31st, 2008 15:00

Can't Upgrade XP home sp/2 with XP Pro that doesn't have SP/2

Ok my new build needed an OS and XP Home sp2 was half the cost of XP pro
and I didn't need XP pro since I have a retail version of the upgrade I bought for a laptop
in 2003 that I no longer use and still have Key/Original CD. 
I installed XP home sp2 with no difficulty.  When I went to upgrade it with my old XP Pro
it states that I cannot upgrade because the version of windows is newer than my PRO upgrade that does not contain SP2.
 
Does anyone know how I can circumvent this to get pro in there?
or do I have to buy Pro w/ SP2
  • Mary G

    6 Operator

    20095 Posts

    203

    0

    Posted January 31st, 2008 15:00

    You would have to do a clean install to get around this and then upgrade to sp2, however, what you want to do is illegal. Operating systems plus any upgrades stay with the first computer, even if that computer is trashed or the operating system is removed. That activation key belongs to the old computer and cannot be used again on the other one. It won't activate.
  • Rebel9

    2856 Posts

    203

    0

    Posted January 31st, 2008 16:00

    Microsoft's answer was correct. I don't know why MaryG keeps posting this garbage.
     
    But to address your problem, you cannot "upgrade" a newer OS with an older OS. In your case, you can't "upgrade" an SP2 version with an original version without SP2. But the solution is very simple. You will have to create a new SP2 slipstreamed XP Pro installation disk. This Google search lists many sites that give you specific instructions. Good Luck.
  • Maui Wowie

    1 Rookie

    117 Posts

    203

    0

    Posted January 31st, 2008 16:00

    I called Microsoft support and they said as long as it is a retail copy I purchased to upgrade
    an OS that was "originally" on PC I can use this upgrade for any PC as long as I have uninstalled the OS or no longer use the PC.
    Thanks for the help but I can't do that b/c SP2 is on the XP home OS I'm using
     
     
  • Maui Wowie

    1 Rookie

    117 Posts

    203

    0

    Posted January 31st, 2008 18:00

    Rich this is a good question....
    I have no idea why I want to upgrade home to pro
    I just figured I had the upgrade paid for it and not using it.
    Isn't it better? "upgrades" are always better right? :smileyvery-happy: (ie-vista)
     
    will XP Pro give my Overclocked BEAST better performance?
  • simpswr

    2 Intern

    3224 Posts

    203

    0

    Posted January 31st, 2008 18:00

    Before going thru all this, why do you want to install XP Pro . . what features do you need that Home does not have?
  • Maui Wowie

    1 Rookie

    117 Posts

    203

    0

    Posted January 31st, 2008 19:00

    Rebel9
    check this link do you mean this?
     
     
    or
     
     
    which In your opinion is better I like the latter of the two seams easier to follow


    Message Edited by Maui Wowie on 01-31-2008 04:08 PM
  • Maui Wowie

    1 Rookie

    117 Posts

    203

    0

    Posted January 31st, 2008 19:00

    great article I wish I read it a long time ago
    that being said if I didn't have the upgrade already I'd say "heck yeah I'm sticking with home"
    but I already have it and If I remember it was freaking expensive!!!
    I'm going to try and at least use it....
    lets just hope it doesn't crash my PC
  • simpswr

    2 Intern

    3224 Posts

    203

    0

    Posted January 31st, 2008 19:00

    Unless you have a need for the features in Pro, it's a waste of time .  .Pro is no better, it offers some additional features that 99% of home users will never use.
     
    For a comparison:  http://www.winsupersite.com/showcase/windowsxp_home_pro.asp
     
     
  • Rebel9

    2856 Posts

    203

    0

    Posted January 31st, 2008 19:00

    I followed Thurrott's instructions (your second link).
  • Maui Wowie

    1 Rookie

    117 Posts

    109

    0

    Posted February 1st, 2008 03:00

    I have a newer XP pro upgrade CD w/ sp2 but am already using the Key it came with on another pc can I use that CD but use my product key from the Older XP pro version?