UNSOLVED

KnaufIT

updated

18 years ago

K

KnaufIT

2 Intern

318 Posts

0

25242

August 28th, 2008 09:00

Swapping OSs between two Dells

Speaking purely hypotheticaly, and forgetting drivers and such, if you have a Dell that shipped with Vista and a Dell that shipped with XP, can you swap the OSs over (Using the Vista disc with the XP PC and the XP disc with the Vista PC)?

 

You'd still have 1 PC with Vista and 1 PC with XP, just in the opposite order to that which was shipped to you. Is this permitted under Dell's OEM? or would this be a no no?

 

I usually use a bulk deal so this is new terretory for me.

  • fireberd

    11 Legend

    33398 Posts

    112846 Points

    1159

    0

    Posted August 28th, 2008 09:00

    The OS that ships with a PC is legally only licensed for the PC it was delivered with. 

     

    Same way if you bought an OEM version of Windows, it is legally only licensed for one PC (the PC it was initially installed on).

    Inspiron 16 5630 Laptop and WD22TB4 Docking Station
    Self-built desktop for recording studio application
  • KnaufIT

    2 Intern

    318 Posts

    1159

    0

    Posted August 28th, 2008 09:00

    I kinda got the impression that this was the case when you didn't have a bulk deal. I take it that Microsoft/Dell won't allow you to register the OS with a different machine (No way to make this legal)?

     

    Boy, home users get a raw deal these days, don't they. It's certainly best to buy retail if you plan to do anything other than using your PC out of the box for the rest of its time.

  • kisianik

    893 Posts

    1159

    0

    Posted August 28th, 2008 14:00

    My dear friend Knaufit, please check your PM (on very top) - you have mail....
  • tommyo1954

    1527 Posts

    1159

    0

    Posted August 28th, 2008 17:00

    Message Edited by tommyo1954 on 08-29-2008 03:37 PM
  • fireberd

    11 Legend

    33398 Posts

    112846 Points

    1159

    0

    Posted August 28th, 2008 18:00

    What I stated was how it's licensed (and it's not just Dell, if you buy an HP, Gateway, Acer, or whoever the OEM versions are the same).

     

    What you do is up to you.

    Inspiron 16 5630 Laptop and WD22TB4 Docking Station
    Self-built desktop for recording studio application
  • KnaufIT

    2 Intern

    318 Posts

    1159

    0

    Posted August 29th, 2008 06:00

    So, long story short, Your OS can only legally be run on the PC that it was purchased with, and neither Dell nor Microsoft will let you reassign it.

     

    One more question. If I'm combining parts from two old PCs (Both Dells), how much of the PC do I need to retain in order to retain the OEM. Motherboard, HD, etc?

  • KnaufIT

    2 Intern

    318 Posts

    1159

    0

    Posted August 29th, 2008 10:00

    Yep, I'm well aware of all of this. Let me give you a hypothetical situation.

     

    Suppose that you had an old Dell and a new Dell, the new Dell is Vista, but the old Dell is XP. Could you hypothetically transfer the OEM of XP to the PC sold with Vista simply by transfering enough of the parts like the HD across and DVD-ROM over. Or does the OEM reside with a significant and non movable component like the motherboard or PSU?

     

    I'm not used to the limitations of a consumer OEM, so I don't know what you can and can't do, and I don't want to do somethig that I'm not supposed to do.

     

    I usualy work bulk business deals and retail installs.

  • fireberd

    11 Legend

    33398 Posts

    112846 Points

    1159

    0

    Posted August 29th, 2008 10:00

    Not sure what you mean, but the Dell supplied OS discs will only load on a system with a Dell BIOS, so you need a Dell motherboard.
    Inspiron 16 5630 Laptop and WD22TB4 Docking Station
    Self-built desktop for recording studio application
  • pcgeek11

    2 Intern

    1874 Posts

    1159

    0

    Posted August 30th, 2008 10:00

    Here is the skinny on this subject:

     

    Microsoft defines the motherboard as the original computer for OEM purposes. Period.

     

    Dell and others use a SLP installation and the code that tells the OS that it is legal is written in the ACPI Table in the BIOS Firmware on the motherboard with respect to the certificate on the OEM installation disk.

     

    The motherboard that came with XP will NOT have the proper code to activate the Vista OS and vice versa as these codes are different for each OS. " Dell M07 for Vista " and " Dell M08 for XP " are the SLP codes.

     

    There is no amount of manipulation that will make it conform to the license agreement.

     

    pcgeek11

    Message Edited by pcgeek11 on 08-30-2008 06:40 AM
  • tommyo1954

    1527 Posts

    891

    0

    Posted August 30th, 2008 11:00

    :smileyvery-happy:

     

    Maybe I didn't word it correctly.. unless I'm missing something... Being the pessimist I can sometimes be, I said the tire wouldn't work, lol. 

    In other words I was meaning to the o.p. to use his/her own good judgement as you're likely to get 5 different opinions from 5 different folks...

     

    Gee...  Who would think that a flat tire I encountered 50 years ago would come up here in 2008..