Hi Dan,

most likely your SATA drives are now in the clarata_archive pool

new SATA drives you could configure either with 6+1R5 or 4+1R5 or 8+1R5 if you want them to also be in clarata_archive

two 6+1R5 plus a hot spare fills a DAE nicely

or do 4+2R6 or 6+2R6 or 12+2R6 but then they would go into clarata_r6

If you want to go Raid6 and have only one ATA pool I would create 12+2R6 for the new disks, move the file systems using Replicator and reconfigure the old disks as a 6+2R6

Personally I think 6+1R5 is reasonable with SATA disks if you have your alerting configured so that you know about broken disks immediately

Rainer

What are your thoughts on the 2TB drives?  Would going with a R5 6+1 be unreasonable for a rebuild time?  The price/GB is neglible between the 1TB and 2TB (comparing a full shelf of 1TB and a shelf with 8 2TB drives - but getting the 1/2 full shelf would give me some expansion done the road)

Dan

thanks - but that document is a bit dated :-)

if you are bored (i think you are ..it's 22:40 in Munich )..this document has rebuild information

https://community.emc.com/docs/DOC-6261

personally I prefer to have at least two raidgroups like 2x 4+1R5    We do benefit from having multiple devices per fs since we can queue more outstanding IOs which can be more important than the sheer number of disks    I haven't seen rebuild times - maybe the Clariion forum has more info      Rainer

that's all i got, you are welcome to post some docs from CSPEED website

After some deliberation, we've decided to go with 1TB 7200RPM drives with two R5 6+1 raidgroups - it's the least painful as far as moving data around.  I already have an R5 8+1 500GB set in this pool and with some other gyrations I could have a 4+1 500GB to add if this doesn't hold me out until I can go back for more.  

One last question ...How many LUNs do I need to use on these RAID groups?  In the past I remember that there was a 2TB limit on the LUN size - if this is still the case, would I bind 3 or 4 since a 6+1 yields roughly 5.4TB?  I'm sure there is a doc out there that covers this - heading over to powerlink to see if I can dig it up...

Dan

Thats good to split the LUN's between SP's but in later versions of Dart you can create a single LUN also.

Sameer

Make the number of LUNs even so you can split them between the SP’s. 4 should work.

Just to close the loop on this -

As stated before, I went with 1TB drives but I'm replacing the 500GB hot spare in my other shelf so I can have three 4+1 R5 groups instead of two 6+1's.  I'll end up with the same space (12 drives worth after RAID overhead).  For the extra bucks, the shorter rebuild times and the common remark about the Celerra working "mo betta" with more RG's I feel it was worth the (relative) small expense.

Thanks for all the comments and words of wisdom.

Dan