UNSOLVED

2350

updated

19 years ago

2

2350

2 Intern

•

1091 Posts

0

9387

December 14th, 2007 03:00

The truth or not

I pulled the following off of the clean up center for windows. This is part of the microsoft website to update windows.

The Windows Registry is the place on your PC where Windows stores information it might need to retrieve later--for example, when you open an application or change a system setting. The registry contains profiles for each user, the applications installed on the computer and the types of documents they create, what hardware exists on the system, and the ports being used.

Over time, the Windows Registry can begin to contain information that's no longer valid. Maybe you uninstalled an application without using the Add or Remove Programs function in the Control Panel, or perhaps an object or file in the registry got moved. Eventually this orphaned or misplaced information accumulates and begins to clog your registry, potentially slowing down your PC and causing error messages and system crashes. You might also notice that your PC's startup process is slower than it used to be. Cleaning your registry once a month via the Windows Live OneCare safety scanner is the easiest way to help avoid these common problems.

While this is fairly easy to understand, I have heard both sides to this. Some people say that you should clean the registry and other's say that you shouldn't. What I would like to see is an article on why you should not clean the registry. When I say clean, I mean use a software program to do the task. I don't mean editing the registry manually because that is not a smart move to make.

Justin

  • jmwills

    2 Intern

    •

    11984 Posts

    213

    0

    Posted December 14th, 2007 06:00

    The best Registry Cleaner of all is a clean install.
  • joe53

    5 Journeyman

    •

    5772 Posts

    •

    17269 Points

    213

    0

    Posted December 14th, 2007 06:00



    2350 wrote:
     
    ... I have heard both sides to this. Some people say that you should clean the registry and other's say that you shouldn't. What I would like to see is an article on why you should not clean the registry. When I say clean, I mean use a software program to do the task..

    Justin


    http://www.whatthetech.com/2007/11/25/do-i-need-a-registry-cleaner/
  • msgale

    2 Intern

    •

    2507 Posts

    213

    0

    Posted December 14th, 2007 11:00

    2350, Please give a link to the site you are quoting.
  • Rebel9

    1 Rookie

    •

    2856 Posts

    214

    0

    Posted December 14th, 2007 12:00

    "Cleaning your registry once a month via the Windows Live OneCare safety scanner is the easiest way to help avoid these common problems"
     
    And of course Microsoft wants to SELL you Windows Live OneCare.
  • tommyo1954

    1527 Posts

    213

    0

    Posted December 14th, 2007 12:00

    Years ago I totally botched up my computer by fussin' around with something called Reg Supreme. I was an idiot.... trying to fix something that wasn't  even broke in the first place.
    Lesson learned....  leave well enough alone if all is running well for you.....:smileywink:
     
     
  • 2350

    2 Intern

    •

    1091 Posts

    214

    0

    Posted December 14th, 2007 12:00

  • mombodog

    2 Intern

    •

    12735 Posts

    143

    0

    Posted December 14th, 2007 20:00

    I typically don't use registry cleaners unless there is a problem that needs a registry cleanup to solve it, like a program that I uninstalled and now cannot install a newer version because of the sloppy uninstaller left registry entries behind.
     
    Trying the Live Care safety scanner now, just to see what it returns after the scan. :smileytongue:
     
    Vista by the way.
     
     
    Check the Note at the bottom, It never gave me the Option of choosing, this could take forever :smileymad:
     
    Won't let me do just a registry scan, no time for a full scan now, later on maybe.
     
    OneCaresaftyscanner.jpg picture by mombodog





    Message Edited by mombodog on 12-14-2007 05:24 PM




  • 2350

    2 Intern

    •

    1091 Posts

    214

    0

    Posted December 14th, 2007 20:00

    I don't want to get confused about registry cleaners. It's just that sometimes I don't really know what to believe and not believe. I used registry cleaners in the past and I never had one problem come up.
    Justin
  • 2350

    2 Intern

    •

    1091 Posts

    143

    0

    Posted December 14th, 2007 20:00

    There is an option to clean the registry using the live care center.
    Justin
  • datapod

    2 Intern

    •

    371 Posts

    214

    0

    Posted December 14th, 2007 20:00

    I've never used a registry cleaner.

    My rule of thumb is, "What problem are you experiencing that you know beyond a shadow of a doubt is going to be solved by using a registry cleaner?"

    If the answer is "I don't know" then logic suggests that the potential for harm is greater than any perceived benefit.

    Anecdotally my Dimension 8200, Inspiron 8500, and Dimension 8400 are all still working on their original install of XP. (upgraded to SP2 on two) They still run as well as ever. All have had a ton of software and hardware installed and uninstalled over the years.

    In all the years I have been troubleshooting computers I have never seen any hard data showing that a registry cleaner has improved a computers functionality.

    Conversely I have seen hundreds of posts over the years that start "I used (fill in a brand) registry cleaner and now my (fill in the blank) no longer works, help."

    HTH