
UNSOLVED
Celeron D vs. Intel Pentium 4
Good Morning,
What is the "pitfall" of having
Intel Celeron D Proc. vs.
Intel Pentium 4 Proc.? Will it be like comparing a Snail to Cougar or more like comparing a fly to an airlplane (both are pretty fast, but one is bigger than the other)
Responses (5)
Solutions (0)
- The Celeron D is generally comparable the a Northwood Pentium IV while current PIVs are built on the Prescott core and have more cache a deeper pipeline and are signifigantly faster at some task. If you plan to do anything CPU intensive (gaming, video editing, etc...) spring for the PIV, you won't regret it.
- i have friends who have celeron Ds and Pentium 4s. They both have the same game Microsoft Flight Simulator 2004. On the celeron D it tends to lag here and there. On the pentium 4 although it makes the fan roar after hours of play, no lags, and the game play is very smooth. On my celeron (not celeron D) the game tends to lag a bit more than celeron D but not often. Hope that helped.Here are the clock speeds of the tested processorsCeleron : 2.60GHZCeleron D: 3.20GHZPentium 4: 3.20GHZobviously the celeron is the weakest but good for basic home needs celeron D is for advanced home needs and Pentium 4 is the best you can get for home use.
Message Edited by ravik521 on 12-02-2005 06:54 PM
- Pentium 4 Celeron - 0128k cache
Pentium 4 Celeron D - 0256k cache
Pentium 4 Wilamette - 0256k cache
Pentium 4 Northwood - 0512K cache
Penitum 4 Prescott E - 1024K cache
More cache does not always translate into better performance.
Its more like marketing. Prescott has a bigger pipeline so even with bigger cache the northwood works faster. Celeron D appears to be based on the prescott core.
Celeron D also has 90 micron process and 533mhz FSB vs 400 and the 31 pipelines like the prescott. Also like the prescott SSE3 - 13 new meaingless instructions (more marketing).
Overall when you combine a Celeron D with 1024K of Ram and a Good Video card it performs as well or better than older Pentium4 systems that are under 2.0A Northwood Spec.
Its a good Budget Chip just like the tualatin Celeron was.

ejn63
11 Legend
•
87468 Posts
•
321253 Points
3712
0
Posted December 2nd, 2005 13:00
For gaming, calculation-intensive work (CAD, modeling, spreadsheets, databases), the difference will be far more pronounced.