UNSOLVED

mdino54

updated

20 years ago

M

mdino54

62 Posts

0

11872

December 2nd, 2006 00:00

External Hard Drive

I am considering adding an external hard drive to my computer for back up purposes as well as extra storage space. Since there is a multitude of options available can someone make some recommendations. I'm not sure what size to consider for home use and also need to know something about speed. Also is there software that is available that allows me to back up my entire system? I'd like to keep this simple and inexpensive.
Mike
  • kirkd

    6 Operator

    5241 Posts

    774

    0

    Posted December 2nd, 2006 01:00

    Most any name brand external drive is OK. Stay away from anything Maxtor for the time being. Too many problems are reported. Speed is not as critical as some think, as the measured speed in benchmarks is seldom seen in real world applications. If you demand better speed, in order of fastest to slowest: eSATA, Firewire, USB. Get the largest capacity you can. A too small drive will not be useful in several years as capacity demands increase. Good deals for large drives are always available. Don't rush. Some popular externals that list at $250 (and are sold there) can be had in the $100 range. eSATA will be the most expensive.
     
    Dimension 9100
    Windows XP SP2 Home
    Intel 630 - 3.0 GHz P4/HT
    2.0 GHz DDR 4300 RAM
    Nvidia GeForce 6800 – O’Clocked to 425/800 MHz
    160 GB Samsung SATA II HD
    300 GB Seagate SATA II HD
    250 GB SimpleTech External HD (WD Drive)
    Sony DVD-ROM, Phillips DVD +/- RW
    Dell 1901 FP Monitor
  • mdino54

    62 Posts

    774

    0

    Posted December 2nd, 2006 20:00

    Thanks for the info. I will take these things into consideration when shopping for the hard drive.
    MIke
  • mdino54

    62 Posts

    774

    0

    Posted December 4th, 2006 11:00

    Dg
    Thanks for the information. I'm shopping as we speak.
    Mike
  • dg27

    2 Intern

    675 Posts

    774

    0

    Posted December 4th, 2006 11:00

    I would also consider the possibility of buying an internal HD and a separate external case. I have three of these setups: These days you can get a 250 Gb Seagate for $60 if you keep track of the prices [try TigerDirect]. There are many manufacturers of cases, but mine are all $30 compusa cases. Installing the drive in the case is 5 minute operation, there are no drivers to load, and it's completely plug and play. I have two machines and leave the USB cables plugged into both and simply swap drives when I want to transfer data from one machine to the other. These setups have been far less problematic than the much pricier option that I also have, which is a Maxtor One Touch II. No problems with the drive itself [I use it strictly for backups], but it can be a pain in terms of the drive "disappearing" from time to time. The data is fine, but periodically I must reinstall the drivers to access it.

    Hope this helps.

    dg
  • dg27

    2 Intern

    675 Posts

    774

    0

    Posted December 4th, 2006 12:00

    One add'l comment regarding what KirkD wrote:

    >>Speed is not as critical as some think, as the measured speed in benchmarks is seldom seen in real world applications. If you demand better speed, in order of fastest to slowest: eSATA, Firewire, USB.

    This is accurate, but in "real world" applications I have found there to be no difference whatsoever between accessing data on my boot drive vs any of my USB 2 external drives. We're in blink of an eye territory in terms of such differences.

    Good luck.

    dg
  • rhinnc

    167 Posts

    774

    0

    Posted December 4th, 2006 14:00

    I recently purchased a 320GB USB/FireWire Hammer drive to be used with my 8400. Very satisfied.
     
    Purchased it the day after thanksgiving from Staples online. Paid 129.00, with a 50.00 mail in rebate. Net will be 79.00.
     
    Comes with Firewire and USB cables. I am running Firewire and am very pleased.
     
  • dg27

    2 Intern

    675 Posts

    774

    0

    Posted December 4th, 2006 14:00

    That is a good deal.

    I'm more comfortable with Seagate's track record and this one is available now:

    Seagate 250GB USB 2.0 External Hard Drive from $87 shipped

    The Seagate 250GB USB 2.0 External Hard Drive, model no. ST3250824U2RK, costs $106.95 with free shipping at Buy.com. Already the lowest no-rebate price we've seen, pay via Google Checkout and it drops further to $86.95. This 7200 rpm drive features an 8MB cache.

    http://dealmac.com/deals/Seagate-250-GB-USB-2-0-External-Hard-Drive-from-87-shipped/143097.html

    dg
  • rhinnc

    167 Posts

    774

    0

    Posted December 4th, 2006 19:00

    I had considered the Seagate, but it only has USB support and I wanted firewire. Nonetheless it is a good buy!