UNSOLVED

sugar_bearz

updated

22 years ago

S

sugar_bearz

29 Posts

0

4942

March 30th, 2005 11:00

SP2

I have delayed installing SP2 on my Dell Inspiron 8200 because of all the problems I hear that others are encountering during and after installation.  I heard Microsoft had done (or is still doing) some tweaking to the SP2 update and I come here periodically to see if there are still as many problems.  It seems there are.  Does anybody know why?  What IS the problem?  I do not recall any other update being so troublesome.  What is the problem with this one?  Any chace that at some point in the future one will be able to download and install it without problems?  Does anybody know what percentage of people are actually having problems after install at this time?  I've heard it said that SP2 is needed but I really do not have time to have my computer down and me pulling my hair out!  Any thoughts on this are appreciated.  Thanks!
R
  • Flooby

    2 Intern

    •

    3031 Posts

    397

    0

    Posted March 30th, 2005 12:00



    @sugar_bearz wrote:
    I have delayed installing SP2 on my Dell Inspiron 8200 because of all the problems I hear that others are encountering during and after installation.  Many of which are caused by either an already compromised system (i.e., the presence of malware, viruses, or other unsupported junkware) or operator error (inadequate planning and preparation, failure to back up critical data in advance, etc.).
     
      I heard Microsoft had done (or is still doing) some tweaking to the SP2 update  just as they do for all of their products that haven't reached EOL (End Of Life) status and I come here periodically to see if there are still as many problems.  There is little that MS (or anyone else, for that matter) can do to prevent the aforementioned compromised systems or other operator error.
     
      It seems there are.  Does anybody know why?  See above, re: "inadequate preparation, compromised systems," etc.
     
     What IS the problem?  None whatsoever, on the multiple systems I've installed SP2, including a variety of desktop and portable platforms.  I do not recall any other update being so troublesome.  You must have missed the great "Windows ME" rollout catastrophe, then.  Most of that was operator error, too.  What is the problem with this one?  Bad karma?  Any chace that at some point in the future one will be able to download and install it without problems?  You can do it right now, if you (once again) adequately prepare for it.  SP2 is a significant update, involving multiple changes to the core OS.  It's not quite as drastic as a format and clean installation of the OS, but it's a good idea to treat it similarly, given the number of changes it makes to the system.  In other words, don't expect it to install properly on a drive that's full of trash and malware.  Don't expect it to install properly on a system with remnants of a host of viruses.  Don't expect it to install properly on a system that you haven't first closed unnecessary applications on.  Read the download/installation instructions first, follow the steps for ensuring a successful installation, make sure your critical files are backed up to external media, and pay attention to the installation process and prompts, so you know what's going on and how to recognize any problems that may occur during and after the installation.  Does anybody know what percentage of people are actually having problems after install at this time?  Far more than is necessary or reflective of the quality of the product, but then there's that old "inadequate preparation" and "operator error" variable to consider again...
     
    I've heard it said that SP2 is needed It is, and, come April 12th, it won't be possible to block the download/installation of it, so it's probably a good idea to start preparing for the inevitable.  but I really do not have time to have my computer down and me pulling my hair out!  So, start reading up on the process, make sure the system is in good shape prior to installing it (this is the responsibility of the operator, not Microsoft or Dell), and follow the recommended steps for installation.  Worst case scenario (and recommended, if you have any question as to your ability to properly prepare the system for SP2 any other way), consider a clean installation of the core OS immediately prior to the installation of SP2.  If you don't know how to do this properly, take it to someone who does.  It's unrealistic to presume or expect that you will never have to reinstall the OS (after all, there is that "operator error" factor to be considered), so you may as well take the bull by the horns and learn something about these devices on which you depend.

  • scottls

    3 Posts

    397

    0

    Posted March 31st, 2005 06:00

    I agree with Flooby about it being best starting SP2 with a new OS (NEVER do a "quick NTFS format"!). Enable firewall ASAP (Control panel, Network Connections, RIGHT click on your network icon, Properties, Advanced...)!

    Do nothing but "Express Install/priority updates" Windows Updates- until no more, then  "Custom Install" over and over until done.

    You might consider getting "high speed internet", as I had a total of about 200mb of updates (SP2 was only about half!)! Fast Dial-up= 200mb x 4min per mb= 800min, Divided by 60= 14 hours! Do not do anything else on computer during updates (or they abort!)! My cable internet does 1mb every 6 seconds=  about 20 minutes total!

  • 397

    0

    Posted April 8th, 2005 01:00

    WARNING: XP SP2 is not supported by Dell. 

    After installing Windows XP2 on a Dimension 4600c, it blue screened, crashed and burned and I have been in Dell misery ever since.  After countless support calls and lost productivity, Dell's offshore contractor informed me that Dell acknowledges that many of its machines will not operate correctly after installation of SP2 and, therefore, the company advises that the hard drive of these defective computers be wiped and the system recovered from scratch.

    The problem with that advice is that, in this case, XP2 fatally crashed the machine and even the Geek Squad could not recover it.  Worse yet, this particular machine was out of warranty, so Dell washed their corporate hands of it.  As a result, we will never purchase from Dell again.  Moreover, Dell's direct model doesn't work for us anymore on desktops and notebooks anyway, let alone servers.  We now only deal with local merchants who appreciate our business and who stand by their sales; local service is now more than a luxury for us, it is a prerequisite.  Dell's relentless advertising and price cutting won't even redeem this lost relationship.  Finally, no more boxing up and shipping defective Dell computers.

    NeverAgainDude!

  • VBdotNet

    415 Posts

    397

    0

    Posted April 8th, 2005 22:00



    @neveragaindude wrote:

    WARNING: XP SP2 is not supported by Dell. 


    I would have liked to see a link supporting such a strong statement.
     
    With my iXPS (gen1)  I had no success installing SP2 over XP Pro SP1 until I figured out how to create a slipstreamed SP2 install CD from my Dell recovery CD. Only when I used the slipstreamed CD to reformat the HD and reinstall XP Pro SP2 did SP2 work on my machine with no problems.
     
    What saved me when I was trying to install SP2 over SP1 was the fact that I used Ghost to image my machine before I started - so I could restore it to SP1 after any SP2 install failures. I did not bother trying to uninstall SP2 as I did not trust the uninstall.
     
    On my home page, I documented the procedure that I used for creating a slipstream SP2 install CD from my Dell XP Pro SP1 recovery CD. I believe that for those systems that do not do well with installing SP2 over the current install, that a slipstream reinstallation may be the answer to a successful upgrade to SP2.

    Message Edited by VBdotNet on 04-08-2005 07:11 PM