Ed111

updated

6 years ago

E

Ed111

4 Posts

0

2333

August 24th, 2020 07:00

Second screen

Hi folks, Can anyone help?

I use an Inspiron 5577 for displaying PowerPoints and videos in a church.

The laptop is connected via an HDMI cable (only one HDMI port on the laptop) to a ceiling-mounted projector which projects the image onto a screen which is painted onto a wall.

The laptop is on a desk off to the side and is operated by a member of the church.

The problem is, I have to turn to see the screen (song words etc.) and the viewing angle is very acute.

Ideally, I would like a monitor nearby which mirrors what the projector is showing.

Is it possible to do this wirelessly, as running any cables would be very difficult and look unsightly - if not, is it possible to do so with cabling?

Appreciate any help.

Ed.

 

  • jphughan

    11 Legend

    •

    13985 Posts

    •

    79931 Points

    1972

    0

    Posted August 24th, 2020 08:00

    @Ed111  Get the Microsoft Wireless Display adapter here. It plugs into an HDMI input of a display or TV (and also requires USB power, so try to get a display or TV that includes a USB port for simplicity), and then you can project wirelessly to it from your system.  It uses point-to-point WiFi though, so the laptop and wireless HDMI adapter will need to be reasonably close to each other.  Additionally, if you're currently using the laptop's own display and the ceiling-mounted projector in Extend mode, i.e. to display different content, then you might be stuck, because I don't think Windows allows you to say, "Have Display #1 (laptop) and Display #2 (ceiling projector) operate in Extend mode, but set up Display #3 as a Mirror of Display #1 (laptop)", for example.  I think with Windows you either have to be all mirrored or all extended.  If you need to achieve a "hybrid" setup like I just described because the person sitting at the laptop wants to use Presenter View in PowerPoint while showing the slideshow on the projector, then you'd probably need to connect an HDMI splitter to the laptop so that just the HDMI signal can be mirrored between the projector and this additional display you'd be purchasing.  But then you'd have to run a cable from the splitter to wherever you want to use this additional display.

  • jphughan

    11 Legend

    •

    13985 Posts

    •

    79931 Points

    1937

    0

    Posted August 25th, 2020 09:00

    @Ed111  One other note I'll add.  If possible, try to get a display with a native resolution that matches whatever you're sending to the projector.  If you have a reasonably recent projector, it should accept a 1080p signal, in which case you should get a 1080p display.  If you have an old projector that only accepts something like 1280x720 or 1366x768, then you'll have a hard time finding a display with a resolution that low, in which case there's nothing to be done about that.  (Desktop PC displays with sub-1080p resolution often use something like 1600x900, which isn't typically found on projectors since projectors tend to align with TV resolutions, and that resolution hasn't been used on TVs.)  But the ideal here is to have the projector and display designed for the same "native resolution", since that way you can send the same signal to both and they'll both look their best.  If the native resolutions of the projector and display don't match, then you'll only be able to use the highest resolution common to both of them, but in that situation, whichever target device has a higher native resolution won't look as good as it could otherwise.

  • Ed111

    4 Posts

    1982

    0

    Posted August 24th, 2020 08:00

    Hi,

    Thanks for your reply. As the set-up is in a church we don't have a TV there.

    I just need a monitor so that I don't have to twist around to see the screen that the congregation can see.

    Ed.

     

  • nyc10036

    6 Operator

    •

    5640 Posts

    1985

    0

    Posted August 24th, 2020 08:00

    You shouldn't need a second screen.

    I have my laptop's screen mirror/duplicate to the TV via HDMI. The same image on the laptop's screen is on the TV.

     

    .

  • Ed111

    4 Posts

    1953

    0

    Posted August 25th, 2020 04:00

    Thank you jphughan for your reply. Your solution is perfect - I need the display to show the same as the projector so the "hybrid" solution won't be necessary. I had thought of using a splitter, but I didn't really want the hassle of running in a cable as hiding the cable would mean taking the platform apart ! As the new monitor will only be about ten feet away from the laptop your wireless solution should work brilliantly. Thanks again for taking the time to reply, it is much appreciated. Kind regards, Ed.

     

  • jphughan

    11 Legend

    •

    13985 Posts

    •

    79931 Points

    1941

    0

    Posted August 25th, 2020 08:00

    @Ed111  Happy to help!  Although to be clear, the question was whether the laptop display needed to show the same content as the projector.  I wasn't sure that you can have the laptop display showing Content A while having the projector and this wireless display both mirroring Content B.  But having played with this a bit in Windows, it turns out you can!  As I write this, I have two external displays connected to my laptop.  The laptop display is #1, and the two externals are #2 and #3.  I went into Windows Display Settings, selected Display #2, and set it to "Duplicate this on Displays 2 and 3".  That caused the external displays to be treated as a single unit, but I could still show completely separate content on my laptop's built-in display.

    However, apparently what you CANNOT do is mirror the same image across all three displays.  A mirror can only involve two displays, at least based on what I've been able to achieve while tinkering.  So in your case, the laptop's built-in display will need to be showing something OTHER than whatever you're showing on both the projector and this new wireless display.  But if you're using PowerPoint, that should actually be fine, and in fact may be preferable.  If whoever is running that display hasn't checked out PowerPoint's "Presenter View", mention that to them.  Basically, you go into PowerPoint and set which display you want to use for Presenter View and which display should be used for the slideshow (in your case, the single "virtual" display that is mirrored between your projector and wireless display).  The slideshow will display on those external displays, and the person looking at the laptop's display will see some presenter controls, any notes on the slides, and even a view showing which slide is coming up next.  It's a nice tool.

    Good luck!

  • Ed111

    4 Posts

    1916

    0

    Posted August 30th, 2020 01:00

    Many thanks again for your comprehensive reply, and for sharing your knowledge. We do use PowerPoint with presenter mode on the laptop, so I think it will all work well. The monitor I will use (which will actually be the third monitor as I always forget to count the one on the laptop!) is 1080p resolution, as is the laptop and the projector, so, again, all should be well. Thanks again.