I am looking at replacing the optical drive in my Inspiron 6000 and would like to get opinions and any info I can on certain drives. Due to cost I will not be purchasing them through Dell rather an on-line store. If you have any experience with these drives (good or bad), I would appreciate your input. I know the Sony and NEC have been used in this model but do not know anything about them.
Pioneer DVR K05 (Slot load)
Sony DW D56A
NEC ND-6500
The NEC 6500 is considered to be a very good laptop drive.
The problem with buying a DVD burner from anywhere else but Dell is that the front faceplate of the drive will not match the contours of your laptop. This is fine if you don't care about the cosmetics but many folk like everything to match.
This is true about the bezel. I know the NEC is a perfect fit and I can purchase it at half the cost of what Dell is asking. I am really intrigued by the possibility of the slot load feature of the Pioneer. Thanks.
I tested out both Sony and NEC drive...
Here is some of my finding...
---
Seems like NEC ND6500A is better...
ex. I am using Dynex 8x +R media (RITEK R03) on both drives...
Sony can only burn at 4x, but NEC can burn at 8x
Same as for mine Ridata 8x +R media as well..
As for the third media I tried, ESA 8x +R (CMC MAG E01), NEC will burn at 6x, but Sony won't even recongize it...
Sometimes Sony couldn't even burn DVD+R media... overall Sony is pretty unstable...
I would say stay away... I am very happy with my NEC drive now...
Yeah, you can get NEC drive at half price compare to Dell...
Only problem is you need to remove the caddy from your current drive and hook onto the new NEC drive...
It's pretty easy, just remove 6 screws, and double sided tape on the front of the drive...
Thanks for the info. My drive does not use a caddy it only has a small bracket on the back end held by two screws. I actually placed an order for the NEC drive this morning. Hope it works out.
Hi bacillus.............about the 6650.......yeah but wouldn't you want the newest technology for only 20 bucks more?? As well as if double layer recording ever becomes fashionable, 90% of the retail home dvd players play dvd-r.
So if you make a copy of something that you would want to play on your tv's dvd player dvd+r won't work
bacillus
2 Intern
•
14378 Posts
139
0
Posted July 14th, 2005 21:00
The problem with buying a DVD burner from anywhere else but Dell is that the front faceplate of the drive will not match the contours of your laptop. This is fine if you don't care about the cosmetics but many folk like everything to match.