you need to set the new printer as a default printer

The old printer was removed and the new printer is set as the default printer but it still prompts me with "Save" instead of "Print" when I attempt to print a page

you need to set the new printer as default (if there is a save option instead of print then the one note(or something like that) is set as default

rmoorenu,

Try reinstalling the printer using the instructions below...

First run Delete Print Jobs to remove stuck print job(s) from the queue, then restart your computer.

Make sure the printer is not usb cable connected.

Start, control panel, programs and features, your printer, uninstall.

Restart your computer. Make sure the printer was removed. Manual Printer Driver Removal

If you have the printer disk, with the computer online, insert the printer disk, choose network, additional computer, then follow the instructions. Your desktop should find the wireless printer. If you don't have the printer disk, try downloading the proper drivers from HP's Website

Remember virus programs and firewalls will block communications.

Rick

remove all other printers icon listed in devices and printers only HP Envy 5530 printer should be there

hope it will solve the issue