Windows Boot Manager should be the new SSD but after cloning did you disconnect or remove the old drive before restarting the computer? You should do that before a restart and after confirming that the system boots off the new drive then reconnect then old drive. You did not specify whether the old drive was an M.2 SSD or an HDD. 

Ha, we posted at the same time and it appears your "easiest" option answers the earlier question I had.  I think I answered your earlier question in my post as well.  

It is my understanding that the NVME in a PCIe slot with an M2 adapter is just as good as being in the M2 slot (speed wise).  So can I just leave the new drive in that slot as the boot drive, format the old drive and use it as a separate data drive?  Thanks so much!

I did not disconnect the old drive, I started the computer up with both drives connected and both possible as a Boot Drive.  The old drive was the OEM drive which was an NVME connected to the m.2 slot.  The new drive is an NVME connected to the PCIe slot via an adapter.

Since I'm currently booted up with the new drive as the boot drive through the manual process (I see the Windows icon and it is labeled C) can I just format the old drive?  I'd prefer not to have to try and open the computer again to disconnect the m.2 drive but will if I need to.

Thanks for the help!

Will need more info. Is this an M2 drive, or did you use an M2 adaptor in a PCIe slot?

The other problem is you have 2 Windows Boot managers. 1 from the original drive, and 1 from the new drive.

Typically the cloning software will detect this and modify the settings to ensure your new drive is the new boot drive.

You can use EasyUEFI, but be very careful and understand what you are doing before changing settings.

A third option would be to boot from the new drive using the one time boot menu and use windows disk manager to format the old drive. Easiest option if you have all the data on the new drive and don't need any of the data on that drive anymore.

So I completely messed something up.  I did what we said and formatted the old Toshiba NVME drive but now the computer can't start up.  I get a recovery screen error no matter what I select.  A few pictures are below.  Please help

https://www.dropbox.com/s/3ghclpgm0wcqqrq/20220929_102937.jpg?dl=0

https://www.dropbox.com/s/9f029la5ao6azj2/20220929_103123.jpg?dl=0

Consider clearing CMOS by removing the CR2032 coin cell battery and discharging flea power.

I tried replacing the new drive into the m.2 slot but am still getting the same issue.  Not sure what got deleted with the format but something got completely messed up.  It is something about the startup because after I formatted the old drive the computer ran fine.  The issue only happened after I restarted.

I tried clearing the CMOS and discharging the flea power.  Didn't fix the problem.  I was getting orange blinking when I first started back up but changed the CR2032 to a new battery and now it starts back up but still get the error screen.  Somehow I've lost Windows Boot Manager. When I go to the Boot List it just says Onboard NIC (IPV4 and IPV6).  There is no longer a choice for Windows Boot Manager in the Boot Option List.  It is weird because it does say HDD1 - Windows Boot Manager (Samsung SSD 970 Evo Plus 1TB) in UEFI options when I hit F12 but it won't start up with that anymore.

Yeah, I wish I knew that before I got started but I'm now already pretty deep in the rabbit hole.  I'm going to try and create a Macrium Reflect Rescue flash drive on another computer. 

If that doesn't work would I then need to reinstall Windows from a flash drive?  Would that even work?  I'm assuming I didn't brick my computer as you must be able to replace a failed hard drive.  Obviously I'd prefer not to have to reinstall Windows or I wouldn't have done the clone but in the end that isn't the worst case scenario for me.  Thanks.