Unsolved

1 Message

2799

April 8th, 2020 08:00

U2720Q, Apple, switching input devices

I have a MacPro (desktop) connected through DP and a MacBook Pro connected through USB Type-C.

I keep the MacBook lid open so I can use the camera and also, if I have selected the DP input, to see what is going on on the laptop.

However, the laptop still "sees" the Dell screen and therefore uses the now non-visible screen estate. Basically, the setup is unusable because I can't see where my application windows are.

Is there a way to configure this behavior? Basically I would expect that when I switch input I mimic the physical act of removing the cable from one of the devices and plug it back into the other device.

Thanks

9 Legend

 • 

14K Posts

April 8th, 2020 10:00

@robcos  I doubt this is configurable.  This would be a firmware-level design decision in the display, and different displays behave differently in this respect.  There are pros and cons to each.  The downside to this display's approach, as you've noticed, is that you can't see what your laptop is displaying in that portion of your overall desktop area when that display is using another input.

But the downside of the opposite behavior that you're requesting is that if the display disconnected itself from the inactive input, your laptop would pull everything onto its main display, and then it would NOT put those application windows back ONTO that display when you switched the input back.  I've seen complaints from other users about that exact behavior when using displays that behave the way you wish yours did, because having to manually reposition all of their application windows onto the external display all the time gets irritating fast, especially if they only need to switch inputs momentarily and/or frequently.

This issue is especially prevalent among people who use KVM systems.  The ones that are generally well-regarded are the ones that deliberately continue advertising the presence of the attached display(s) even to the inactive source system(s), rather than disconnecting them and causing the inactive source to consolidate everything onto the built-in display.  The ones that behave as you're requesting tend to get negative reviews for doing so.

Of course both sides of this discussion have merit, and different use cases will undoubtedly benefit more from one design over the other, so it would certainly be NICE if this behavior were configurable, but I've never seen a display or KVM that offers that customization.

1 Message

October 31st, 2022 22:00

You can achieve the equivalent behavior by going into system settings | displays and set the non-visible monitors to mirror a visible monitor (or your laptop). Depending on what windows you move around while in this state, some may even get restored to the previous monitor when you change back from mirrored to extended

December 19th, 2023 05:10

Can this same thing be done on the Dell Alienware Area 51m laptops?

No Events found!

Top