Unsolved
2 Intern
•
49 Posts
•
19 Points
0
782
October 1st, 2022 12:00
T7910 Precision memory: HYNIX DDR4-2132/PC4-17000 DDR4 compatible with MICRON DDR4-3200?
Hi,
I need help upgrading my Dell T7910 Precision Workstation memory from 64GB to 128GB: is Hynix DDR4-2132/PC4-17000 DDR4 SDRAM RDIMM memory compatible with Micron DDR4-3200 RDIMM memory
I have eight (8) Hynix DDR4-2132 / PC4-17000 DDR4 SDRAM RDIMM EEC 1066 MHz memory sticks for a total of 64 GB. Product number: HMA41GR7MFR8N-TF. My T7910 has sixteen memory slots with eight (8) being free.
I run Windows 10 Professional. My CPU details are appended to this post.
I planned to add another eight (8) Hynix HMA41GR7MFR8N-TF. Unfortunately, all the new ones I found were counterfeit and I did not want refurbished sticks.
A Micron/Crucial memory scan suggests I can add the following memory to my Hynix memory:
- Micron 8GB DDR4-3200 RDIMM 1Rx8 CL22 (MTA9ASF1G72PZ-3G2R) - DDR4-3200MT/s • 8GB Module Capacity • 8Gb Die Density • RDIMM • 1 Rank x 8 • PC4-25600 • CL=22 • Ext Timing 22-22-22 • 1.2V • ECC • Single Pack. Price: $47.49 each, $380 for eight (8), that is, 64GB.
- Micron 16GB DDR4-3200 RDIMM 2Rx8 CL22 (MTA18ASF2G72PDZ-3G2R). DDR4-3200MT/s • 16GB Module Capacity • 8Gb Die Density • RDIMM • 2 Rank x 8 • PC4-25600 • CL=22 • Ext Timing 22-22-22 • 1.2V • ECC • Single Pack Price: $71.41, $286 for four (4), that is 64GB.
- Micron 16GB DDR4-3200 RDIMM 2Rx8 CL22 (MTA18ASF2G72PDZ-3G2R) DDR4-3200MT/s • 16GB Module Capacity • 8Gb Die Density • RDIMM • 2 Rank x 8 • PC4-25600 • CL=22 • Ext Timing 22-22-22 • 1.2V • ECC • Single Pack Price: $71.41 $286 for four (4), that is 64GB.
- Micron 32GB DDR4-3200 RDIMM 2Rx4 CL22 (MTA36ASF4G72PZ-3G2R) - DDR4-3200MT/s • 32GB Module Capacity • 8Gb Die Density • RDIMM • 2 Rank x 4 • PC4-25600 • CL=22 • Ext Timing 22-22-22 • 1.2V • ECC • Single Pack Price: $132.24, $264 for two (2), that is 64GB.
While Crucial lists other Micron memory for my T7910, they do not seem to be available at the sellers it lists on its site. I imagine they are out of stock or no longer produced.
Clearly it would be cheaper to buy two 32GB ($264) sticks than eight (8) 8GB sticks ($380). It would also leave some memory slots free for future memory upgrades.
My questions are:
- Are these Micron memory sticks compatible with my Hynix ones?
- If they are compatible can I install
-
- Two Micron 32GB sticks (or four 16GB ones) or
- am I limited to the 8GB Micron sticks because of compatibility issues?
- If the Micron memory sticks are incompatible with my Hynix ones, should I
-
- Discard them and buy four (4) Micron 32GB sticks (Crucial does not list any Micron sticks beyond 32GB that are available)?
- Look at memory makers other than Micron? Any suggestions would be gratefully received.
- I would also appreciate any suggestions of Micron memory stick sellers other than Crucial
My thanks in advance for your comments and advice
My T7910 CPU
CPU 0 CPU 1
Intel(R) Xeon(R) CPU E5-2637 v3 3.50GHz Intel(R) Xeon(R) CPU E5-2637 v3 3.50GHz
CPU Technology - 22 NM CPU Technology - 22 NM
Stepping - R2 Stepping – R2
Core/Threads - 4/8 Core/Threads - 4/8
SSPEC SR202 SSPEC SR202
uCU 44 uCU 44
Cache 4x32 + 4x32 + 4x256 + 15M Cache 4x32 + 4x32 + 4x256 + 15M


DELL-Cares
Moderator
•
27.8K Posts
•
529 Points
0
October 2nd, 2022 06:00
We tried reaching you on a private message asking for the Service Tag number to ascertain the warranty but did not receive a response. Please feel free to reply to the private message whenever you are available.
Chino de Oro
11 Legend
•
8.4K Posts
•
46.4K Points
0
October 2nd, 2022 22:00
Hello @gakerby Dell machines have been known for very picky about mixing RAM, brands and capacity. Even if you get confirmation from users validation, there is a chance that it might not work with yours.
For example, new sticks of Hynix 32GB can be had for around 50 USD from ecommerce store like A-Tech. With lifetime warranty and free return. Your research, your decision.
gakerby
2 Intern
•
49 Posts
•
19 Points
0
October 3rd, 2022 10:00
Hi, and thanks for your suggestion about the eBay Hynix. Unfortunately, I suspect these are counterfeit. Certainly, they do not have the labeling that the 32GB Hynix sticks have in the Amazon Hynix store. As I said in my post, when I researched Hynix memory sticks I found all the HMA41GR7MFR8N-TF 8GB sticks on Amazon and eBay were counterfeits.
I am reluctant to replace my 8GB Hynix wholly with higher capacity Hynix. My impression is that Hynix memory is not high quality (the Hynix store 32GB sticks got a bad review, for example) .
You write, Dell machines are 'very picky about mixing brands and capacity'. Am I to understand that mixing even different capacities (e.g. 8GB and 16GB) of the same brand (e.g. Hynix) is problematic?
Is there any quality memory brand sold by reputable retailers (not Amazon or eBay) that would work in my T7910? I would prefer to install 64GB or even 128GB (my T7910 has 1TB memory capacity, though I don't know if 1TB would work with my CPU). I'm looking to put in, depending on the price, 128GB.
Thanks again for your reply. I very much appreciate it. It was very helpful to learn about the problem of mixing brands/capacity.
Have a great day.
bradthetechnut
9 Technologist
•
9.6K Posts
•
40.6K Points
0
October 3rd, 2022 18:00
Mixing speeds can also be a problem. It can be hit or miss whether machine will boot or simply downclock RAM to the speed of the slowest stick.
I've used A-Tech RAM for years with no hiccups. I prefer it over the Hynix that went in a previous PC. (Dell seems to prefer Hynix for their OEM.)
However, if in too much doubt over Amazon and eBay, Crucial is a good brand that comes often recommended for Dell's. crucial.com
Chino de Oro
11 Legend
•
8.4K Posts
•
46.4K Points
0
October 4th, 2022 12:00
Being cautious and doing research before hand is a good thing. However, contrary to your finding, many server RAM on the zone and the bay are real things. Vendors parted them out from thousands of units which already reached end of life. When businesses and enterprises flooded markets with off leased and eol machines, they don't retain value and being sold dirt cheap. For example, a high end processor for your machine was over a thousand usd a piece. It's less than a hundred now. So are the RAM and GPU.
It's my perspective and not intend to persuade you into buying anything.
bradthetechnut
9 Technologist
•
9.6K Posts
•
40.6K Points
0
October 4th, 2022 17:00
I forgot you mentioned "other than Crucial" in your first post, my mistake.
gakerby
2 Intern
•
49 Posts
•
19 Points
0
October 13th, 2022 15:00
Hi,
Thanks for your comment. Sorry for being so tardy for getting back to you..
I think I may as well go with four (4) Micron 32GB DDR4-3200 RDIMM PC4-25600 2Rx4 CL22 (MTA36ASF4G72PZ-3G2R). Unfortunately, they’re about $120 each. So far as I can tell 32GB RDIMM memory is priced pretty much the same wherever you look.
I’ve looked for 32GB on eBay but what they have doesn't seem to be that much cheaper than anywhere else.
Final question, I hope, I assume I’m better off with RDIMM rather than just DIMM memory and that there is nothing better I can use than RDIMM.
Thanks again for your comments. I very much appreciate them