All of your steps look correct, but I have two questions.

First, why not simply define a new Quorum disk?  MSCS will let you select a new disk for the Quorum drive and will use it on its own.  It just seems simpler than having a migration tool do it.

Second, have you considered using PowerPath Migration Enabler? If you're using PowerPath on your servers, PPME has a simpler rollback plan and allows you to move your devices one at a time or in groups.  PPME is free, but will use CPU resources on the host to move the data.  We were able to move a 2TB SQL LUN in about 90 minutes with the default settings and no noticeable impact on the server.  You can always throttle a migration to reduce CPU impact or reduce the time needed to complete the migration.

Let us know if that helps!

Karl

Thanks Karl,

Yes, we can create new Quorum drive in new VNX, so am I right that we first move the quorum drive to new VNX and then carry out steps from 3 to 7

I have not used PPME but I can try that

The documentation is a good start, and there are plenty of articles on EMC Support for various issues that can arise.  You can start with the user guide - https://support.emc.com/docu56488_PowerPath-Migration-Enabler-6.x-User-Guide.pdf?language=en_US

Let us know if that helps!

Karl

Hi,

I have tested PPME and it works with no issues, will use migrator to move data, just one question.

The disk numbers assigned are different in both clusters, will that cause any issues

ie when I do diskpart on active node

Disk1 to Disk 11 are newly assigned luns

Disk 12 to Disk 22 are the old luns

so I will copy disk12 to disk1 - Powermig setup –techtype hostcopy –src harddisk12 –tgt harddisk1 –cluster –no

However in passive node it is reverse, disk1 to disk 11 are old luns and disk 12 to disk 22 are newly assigned luns

DISKPART info as below

ACTIVE NODE

DISKPART> list disk

  Disk ###  Status         Size     Free     Dyn  Gpt

  --------  -------------  -------  -------  ---  ---

  Disk 0    Online          100 GB      0 B

  Disk 1    Offline        1024 GB  1024 GB

  Disk 2    Offline         900 GB   900 GB

  Disk 3    Offline        1250 GB  1250 GB

  Disk 4    Offline        1350 GB  1350 GB

  Disk 5    Offline        1025 GB  1025 GB

  Disk 6    Reserved       2048 GB      0 B        *

  Disk 7    Offline         100 GB   100 GB

  Disk 8    Offline         100 GB   100 GB

  Disk 9    Offline         512 MB   512 MB

  Disk 10   Offline         300 GB   299 GB

  Disk 11   Offline         100 GB   100 GB

  Disk 12   Reserved       1024 GB  1024 KB

  Disk 13   Reserved        750 GB  1024 KB

  Disk 14   Reserved       1325 GB  1024 KB

  Disk 15   Reserved        100 GB  1024 KB

  Disk 16   Reserved        300 GB  1024 KB

  Disk 17   Offline         200 GB  1024 KB

  Disk 18   Reserved       1024 GB      0 B

  Disk 19   Reserved        900 GB  1024 KB

  Disk 20   Reserved        500 MB  1920 KB        *

  Disk 21   Reserved        100 GB  1024 KB

  Disk 22   Reserved        100 GB  1024 KB

DISKPART>

PASSIVE NODE

DISKPART> list disk

  Disk ###  Status         Size     Free     Dyn  Gpt

  --------  -------------  -------  -------  ---  ---

  Disk 0    Online          100 GB      0 B

  Disk 1    Reserved       2048 GB      0 B        *

  Disk 2    Reserved       1024 GB  1024 KB

  Disk 3    Reserved        750 GB  1024 KB

  Disk 4    Reserved       1325 GB  1024 KB

  Disk 5    Reserved        100 GB  1024 KB

  Disk 6    Reserved        300 GB  1024 KB

  Disk 7    Reserved       1024 GB      0 B

  Disk 8    Reserved        900 GB  1024 KB

  Disk 9    Reserved        500 MB  1920 KB        *

  Disk 10   Reserved        100 GB  1024 KB

  Disk 11   Reserved        100 GB  1024 KB

  Disk 12   Offline         200 GB  1024 KB

  Disk 13   Offline        1024 GB  1024 GB

  Disk 14   Offline         900 GB   900 GB

  Disk 15   Offline        1250 GB  1250 GB

  Disk 16   Offline        1350 GB  1350 GB

  Disk 17   Offline        1025 GB  1025 GB

  Disk 18   Offline         100 GB   100 GB

  Disk 19   Offline         100 GB   100 GB

  Disk 20   Offline         512 MB   512 MB

  Disk 21   Offline         300 GB   299 GB

  Disk 22   Offline         100 GB   100 GB

DISKPART>

Unless you're doing something very specific, Windows doesn't care about the Logical disk number, it cares about the disk signature.  After you fail cluster disks from Node A to Node B, Node B activates the cluster disk based on signature, not logical disk number.  If the disks are under cluster control, be sure to follow the steps for handling cluster disks, as per the guide.

Let us know how it goes!

Karl

Your steps for Open Migrator are correct. I would add that to attach Open Migrator filter driver to the source and target LUNs it would require a reboot. Also, to uninstall OM would require another reboot. I see Karl directed you to PPME which would be preferred as you can significantly minimize your downtime involved with this migration. Also, SANcopy would do the job if you needed an array-based approach. I almost prefer SANcopy incremental push over OM due to the number of outages I need to incur with OM.

Hi,

We tested the migration using PPME and it works with no issues, we tested it between VNX and XtremeIO ( to and fro)

We checked with EMC and I was told that XtremeIO is supported.

Once question, can I ignrore the powermig cleanup command and remove the abanondend drives first before carrying out the -force cleanup?

If we need to reverse the migration for any reason, we can attach the old source drives as it will still have data if we do not cleanup?

Also as it is Micrsocft cluster, can we leave sync running in sourceselected mode for as long as we want?

Is there a reason you need to use -force with your powermig cleanup?  I only ask, because I can't remember the circumstances it's required.  In my experience, I have always put LUNs into a committed state before taking any further actions.  I would not recommend removing drives once committed - that's what I would use powermig cleanup for.

If you're concerned about an issue that would force you to reverse the migration, I would go into TargetSelected for an extended period of time, and leave things like that for a while. We let a server stay this way for 30 days, to see the impact of month-end processing, then committed and cleaned up the migration.  If we had issues during month-end processing, we were planning to use powermig abort and scrap the whole project.