Unsolved

This post is more than 5 years old

Closed

1 Message

11477

August 8th, 2004 23:00

Choosing a processor

Hello to those of you with more experience with processors than I have,

I want to buy a new notebook, but get hung up on the processors. I do online stock trading and use TradeStation. The tech fellow there advised me to stick with Pentium 4's rather than Pentium M's. Is there anyone out there using TradeStation who could advise me?

Also, I like the 8600 but it only comes with Pentium M.

9100 looks too bulky and heavy to lug around.

I am also looking at a Sony VAIO PK 27, with 3.06 GHz Pentium 4.

Any advice would be most welcome. Wish there was one that had all I want without costing $2600 before I'm done.

Peggylou

2 Intern

 • 

3.2K Posts

August 9th, 2004 00:00

Pentium M is the only way to go.

791 Posts

August 9th, 2004 00:00

If you get the equivalent processor, they basically break down to:

P4 - Runs hotter, lower uptime, cheaper
P-M - Runs cooler, lonnger uptime

Do you do a lot of travelling or plan on using battery often?? If so, then the Pentium M would be best as you can get more uptime out of each charge.

If you plan on plugging it into the ac adapter for most of the time, then the P4 might be good.

Lastly, the Pentium M does run a lot cooler. So on day to day tasks, the fans will rarely turn on (light usage). On the P4, you notice that the fans turn on periodically and can get quite annoying.

All in all, I think the P-M would be the best choice.

11 Posts

August 9th, 2004 07:00

I second that.  I recently bought an 8600 system with a 1.7 Centrino and it's been superb. 

Regards, Dave T

August 9th, 2004 14:00

I third that!

425 Posts

August 9th, 2004 14:00

for mobile i would definitely recommend a Pentium M processor - and if you do get a Penitum M make sure is numbered (i.e. 715, 725, 735, 745, 755 and NOT the 705) that is to make sure you get a newer generation Dothan based.

for a desktop replacement, i would definitely recommend a AMD64 DTR processor between 3000+ to 3400+.

28 Posts

August 10th, 2004 22:00

If it's an option, the P4 Mobile ( not Pentium M) is a really good option.  My 5150 has a P4M and it runs 4 hours off of a single battery charge.

Message Edited by isnoop on 08-10-2004 05:05 PM

29 Posts

August 11th, 2004 07:00

NOOOOOOOOOO!!!!!!!!! NO MATTER WHAT! I REPEAT, NO MATTER WHAT! if your going to buy a laptop, get a Pentium M. i have a 1.6GHz Pentium M and it outperforms my P4 2.73GHz desktop processor by like 30+ points! and as long as you get something higher than that, it'll be FAST!

2 Posts

August 14th, 2004 09:00

For me i would recommend you to buy Pentium 4, i dont trust Mobile Technology . I was interested in Pentium M for a while until i bought this Inspiron 600m notebook, 1.5 Ghz 512MB 2MB L2 cache, 64MB ATI 9000. I've had lots of problem with this laptop. I had to reinstall Windows on the first day i received it. Then the biggest problem that i hate the most is the performance of the CPU....

The Pentium M CPU onli runs at half of its speed or a little bit faster if you leave it on Always On power scheme. I tried to run Need For Speed Undersground and the whole system froze when i quit the game. It said my CPU only run at 200Mhz and the game requires at least 700Mhz...

Through this experience, i would never buy any Dell laptop or PC though they're cheaper than other brands...and i would recommend to not to buy Pentium M. If you can afford more, then go to buy another laptop brand like Sony, Toshiba or Fujitsu...

29 Posts

August 14th, 2004 18:00

that's the way of the chip. i don't like the new dothan pentium m chip. the original Pentium M chip that's on my system is FAST! faster than my desktop's P4 2.68GHz processor. its as fast as a ~2.7GHz in benchmarks. the chip runs on a lower speed when not doing anything on it. but my friend is having a problem with the dothan chip too, when its always on, it runs slower than 600Mhz. i guess i got the last Pentium M chip.

0 events found

No Events found!

Top