5 Posts

3503

May 13th, 2020 12:00

P2219H, dual, work when connecting remotely?

I have an Inspiron 3671 desktop, running Windows 10, with two P2219H monitors in my home. My original set-up had an HDMI cable running from one monitor and a VGA cable running from the other monitor.  When my wife or I log in remotely to our respective office workstations, located elsewhere, using Windows' Remote Desktop Connection or using GoToMyPC we are unable to drag objects (web pages, spreadsheets, documents, etc.) on the remotely-connected workstation's screen from our primary monitor to our second monitor.  Is that even possible?  To try to remedy this I got an HDMI splitter, ran HDMI cables from both monitors to the splitter, then from the splitter to the Inspiron's HDMI port, but ended up with two identical monitor displays. When I go into the display settings it does not detect a second monitor, nor will it allow me to "Extend" the displays in the Multiple Display settings.  Those options are disabled.  Is what I'm trying to accomplish possible when connecting remotely?  Recommendations will be appreciated.  Thank you.

11 Legend

 • 

14K Posts

 • 

79.9K Points

May 13th, 2020 13:00

@MNVOL  I can't speak to GoToMyPC, but Windows Remote Desktop definitely supports multiple displays.  I use this capability on a daily basis.  For clarity with what comes up, I'll establish that the PC you're connecting FROM is the "client" and the PC you are remoting TO is the "host".

When using Remote Desktop, it absolutely does not matter how many displays are physically attached to the host system, since after all you're not sitting in front of that system, and when you use Remote Desktop, the local "console" of the host (i.e. the display(s) physically attached to it) just shows a lock screen, unlike other screen sharing solutions where remote and local users share a common view.  So for example, if the host only has 1 display physically connected to it, but you have 3 on the system you're connecting from, you can use all 3 displays with the host through Remote Desktop.  But if on the other hand the host has 3 displays physically attached to it but you only have 1 display on the client you're connecting from, then you can only use one display in the Remote Desktop session.

When you start a Remote Desktop connection, you have the option to connect to the host using either a single display (the default) or "all displays".  So if you have 3 displays, you can only use 1 or 3 displays for your Remote Desktop session, not 2.  And whatever you choose, the Windows session on the host will behave as if that's how many displays were actually attached to it.  You can even disconnect an active Remote Desktop session (without fully logging off) and then reconnect after choosing a different display option, in which case the host session that you resume will adapt just as if you had physically connected or disconnected a display at that system.

To manage this, when you open the Remote Desktop application on a client with multiple displays attached locally, click "Show Options" in the lower-left corner and go to the Display tab, then check the "Use all my monitors for the remote session" option.

5 Posts

May 15th, 2020 05:00

@jphughan Since you were curious, and for the benefit of others who may view this thread, the tech person at my wife's office was able to figure out the GoToMyPC issue.  What we ended up needing to do is change the screen resolution on our home monitors to more closely match the screen resolution of the monitors of her office workstation that she was logging in to remotely.  Then, after logging in to GoToMyPC she needed to click on the screen maximize icon in the upper right-hand corner of her GoToMyPC session while holding down the Shift key.  That allows her to make use of both monitors.

Thanks again for your assistance.


(Not sure why the Community moderator switched the more generic title of this thread to specifically refer to P2219H.  I doubt very seriously that my issue had anything to do with the specific monitor model I was using.)

11 Legend

 • 

14K Posts

 • 

79.9K Points

May 13th, 2020 14:00

@MNVOL  adding on to my reply above, I forgot to address your HDMI splitter question.  An HDMI splitter will only ever mirror a single source signal to multiple attached displays, because HDMI does not support running multiple independent displays from a single source port.  Only DisplayPort can do that (and USB-C, which uses DisplayPort signaling for video output, assuming the USB-C port in question supports video output at all, which not all do.)  So if you want to have a multi-display Remote Desktop session, first you need multiple displays working properly on the system you're actually connecting from.  Looking at the specs of the Inspiron 3671, it appears the only built-in video outputs are 1x VGA and 1x HDMI -- unless you added a graphics card that would have other inputs.  But assuming you didn't do that, then if you go back to connecting one display via HDMI and one via VGA, you should be able to get back to having simultaneous independent displays, i.e. Extend mode.  At that point, it's just a matter of setting up the Remote Desktop connection to use both of them, which it doesn't by default.

5 Posts

May 13th, 2020 14:00

@jphughan(Let's try this again.  I replied to your original post, but when I clicked "Post" I got an error and my post disappeared.)

Thank you!   I was able to get Remote Desktop Connection to work across two monitors following the instructions on your original post.  My wife and I have tried playing around with GoToMyPC and so far have been unsuccessful.  The only thing we managed to do was pop her original GoToMyPC screen right in the middle across two monitors.  That won't work.  Hopefully a tech support person from her company will be able to give some suggestions.

As an FYI, the workstation that we're remoting from is set up in it's original configuration of one monitor with an HDMI cable and one monitor with a VGA cable. 

(For anyone else reading this thread who's familiar with GoToMyPC, any suggestions would be appreciated.)

Thanks again, @jphughan.

5 Posts

May 13th, 2020 15:00

(Don't know what the issue is, but every time I reply to you I get a37FF74E2 error the first time, but then it posts the second time.)

@jphughanThe workstation that my wife is remoting in to has two monitors.  Hopefully she's be able to talk with a tech support person at her company to see if they have a solution.  Thanks again for your assistance.

11 Legend

 • 

14K Posts

 • 

79.9K Points

May 13th, 2020 15:00

@MNVOL  Glad I was able to help!

Out of curiosity, how many displays are actually attached to the systems you're remoting into?  The reason I ask is that Remote Desktop is a bit special in that it can set up a completely separate user session.  That's why the "console" shows the lock screen when a Remote Desktop connection is active.  In this case, the fact that Remote Desktop uses a capability built into the host OS itself means that when that mechanism is being used, Windows "understands" that the session is actually occurring elsewhere and therefore that it should care about what displays are attached to the client (or at least which displays the client has chosen to use for the connection) rather than which displays are physically attached to the system.  But GoToMyPC is a third-party tool that is simply running on top of Windows, not a remote desktop capability built into Windows itself.  Again, I haven't used it, so I may be wrong here, but my suspicion is that as a result of that distinction, GoToMyPC will NOT be able to just shift the entire Windows session to a purely remote mode the way Remote Desktop can.  Instead, it probably keeps the console active and just allows you to see and interact with that console session.  But in that case, it will matter how many displays are attached to the physical system, since that defines the display area of the console session that's being used even through GoToMyPC.

That's why I asked how many displays were physically attached to the systems you're remoting into.  If there are multiple displays there, and you have multiple displays where you are, then you might be able to have GoToMyPC "map" the remote view of each locally attached display to one of the displays you're actually using.  But if there's only one display physically attached to the system you're remoting into, then the console session that GoToMyPC would be exposing to you remotely would only be a single-display desktop, regardless of what you had available on your client.

11 Legend

 • 

14K Posts

 • 

79.9K Points

May 15th, 2020 07:00

@MNVOL  Thanks for reporting back!  Glad you've got GoToMyPC working if you prefer that solution, although the fix does confirm what I suspected, which is that GoToMyPC is just giving a remote view of a console session rather than establishing a completely independent remote session -- and therefore there's a dependency on the peripherals attached directly to the system.  On the other hand, Remote Desktop is harder to use over the Internet because you really need a VPN solution to secure it.  It just isn't safe to open up port 3389 on your firewall and expose your system's RDP listener to the public Internet.  Even using a non-default port to obscure it still isn't great.  By comparison, GoToMyPC seems to involve the listening host maintaining a connection to GoToMyPC so that when a client wants to connect, GoToMyPC's servers facilitate that connection, obviating the need for a VPN or other direct connection solution.

I personally use LogMeIn Hamachi for VPN purposes when I don't have the access or equipment necessary to set up a "standard" VPN hosted by a firewall router.  Hamachi allows you to create on-demand point-to-point VPNs with practically zero configuration.  It's fantastic.  There's a Free version that allows up to 5 clients, but it only works when the system's console is unlocked.  That works if you're creating a VPN so that multiple active users can exchange traffic, but it doesn't work for remote access where the console will be locked.  For that capability, you need the paid version.

5 Posts

May 15th, 2020 07:00

@jphughan What we use for remote access is controlled by our respective employers.  Mine uses Remote Desktop Connection, along with PulseSecure as the VPN.  The Queen's employer uses GoToMyPC.  

0 events found

No Events found!

Top