Wireless Connects, but laptop cannot see second router

My new Dell e1505 arrived today with included Intel Wireless Software and Card. I have 2 netgear routers (one wireless, one not, see below). The wireless (through windows and intel software with encryption key) is connected to the wireless network, but cannot ping the primary router. I have checked and double checked the key (it connects to the nework though).

My setup is:

Cable Modem > Netgear FVS318 Ethernet Router > Netgear wireless Router.

I entered in the exact same information in the tcp/ip configuration as was on another computer sitting 1 foot away from the laptop, except for the ip address (it is not conflicting with another IP).

I can connect to the wireless router, but i can't ping the FVS318.

Any help is appreciated