Start a Conversation

This post is more than 5 years old

Solved!

Go to Solution

31750

June 10th, 2015 01:00

Dell R710 - Memory Configuration

Hi All,

I'm sure I'm missing something but I've read the two technical documents regarding memory configuration in the Dell R710.

I've got a server that currently has 48GB in laid out as follows

A1 - 4GB

A4 - 4GB

A2 - 4GB

A5 - 4GB

A3 - 4GB

A6 - 4GB

(This is then the same on the B side)

According to the BIOS it's set to 'Optimized'

Now I have 2x16GB Sticks which I wanted to install, the only way I could get it working without the BIOS moaning was to install as follows:

A2 - 16GB

A5 - 4GB

A8 - 4GB

(Duplicated on B side)

Giving 72GB.

As I read the manual I should be able to mix memory sizes for 'optimized' as long as I go from A1 to A9 and so I have a further 6x4GB sticks left I want to install.

My logic is I can fill from A1 to A9, mixing the 16GB in, however when I try I get the error about A1/A2/A3 needing to be the same?

Am I missing something simple? I'm unable to make changes in the BIOS, the memory is all the same type (Purchased from Dell)

Moderator

 • 

8.6K Posts

June 10th, 2015 06:00

Rob_991,

The issue you are running into is due to the R710 needing the 3 memory channels to match.  Each nine-socket set is organized into three channels with three memory sockets per channel. As shown below each processor has 3 memory channels, which when required to match, only allows a single channel to be populated.  So with only having a couple of 16GB dimms, you are only able to populate a channel on each side. What I would suggest is adding a couple more 16GB dimms and populate A1, A2, B1, B2 with them, and then place 4GB in A4,A5,A7, and A8, as well as B4, B5, B7, and finally B8. That gives you two channels on each side, as well as 96GB of memory. 

Let me know if this helps answer your question.

5 Posts

June 10th, 2015 06:00

I see - So when I'm mixing sizes of memory I can't populate all 3 channels?

Currently it has 72GB

A2 - 16GB / A5 - 4GB / A8 - 4GB

B2 - 16GB / A5 - 4GB / B8 - 4GB

I think if I read your reply correctly I should have started these from A1 and leave A3/A6/A9 empty with my current setup?

Moderator

 • 

8.6K Posts

June 10th, 2015 08:00

You could populate all 3 if you like, but you would need a 16GB for all the white slots, and 4GB dimms in all the black slots, that would make the 3 channels match. Your excluded from that bank due to the limited number of 16GB dimms you have.

You will need to start with placing the 16gb dimms in A1 and B1. 

Then the 4gb dimms in 4,5,7, and 8 for A and B.

This does exclude 3,6, and 9 for both sides, as you stated.

5 Posts

June 10th, 2015 08:00

Cheers Chris

5 Posts

June 12th, 2015 00:00

Chris,

Tried the above this morning and it gives an error saying that the memory is geo/size right in A1/A2 .. B1/B2

Have had to go back to my original config of leaving A1/A4/A7 empty to get it to boot.

2 Posts

November 10th, 2023 22:51

@DELL-Chris H​ 

Hi I am rather new to this server and I only have one CPU so if I where to populate A1-A9 and leave B9-B1 empty would the system work?

Thanks

Moderator

 • 

3.9K Posts

13-11-2023 02:24 AM

I believe you are correct on that.

Respectfully,


Professionnel des médias sociaux et des communautés
#IWork4Dell

No Events found!

Top