Unsolved

This post is more than 5 years old

3 Posts

11537

February 6th, 2008 17:00

Shutdown without powerdown

Hi I have a new Inspiron desktop, it works fine except for Vista. The first month I did not have any serious problem with it. Now the system does not poweroff when I try to shutdown, and I have to press the power button.

I can hear the hard disk stop and the screen goes black, but the fans are still running and the monitor remain with the light in green, not in orange. (I never get the error message "the system do not close properly")

After writting to DELL's Support we tried the following:

Start in safe mode and try to shutdown --> That works
Start in normal mode and:

1.- Try to disable all the services and start programs using "msconfig" --> Doesn't Work
2.- Restore the system to a previous state --> Doesn't work
3.- Re-installing the fabric image --> Works

The problem seems to be solved by hard force, but one month later the problem comes again. And I don't want to reinstall Vista once per month, any suggestion?

2 Intern

 • 

1.9K Posts

February 6th, 2008 18:00

Something is installed... A Windows Update, Dell update, will be hard to find what exactly is causing the problem. If it doesn't happen on SafeMode, for sure, it is a startup item, a service...  1.- Try to disable all the services and start programs using "msconfig" --> Doesn't Work What about Microsoft services...??? As i remember Dell says to disable all non MS services, what about a MS service, just in case.

137 Posts

February 7th, 2008 10:00

I would guess that this is an automatic update problem (assuming that you haven't installed new hardware and drivers).  Because it occurs a few weeks after a clean image restore, my guess is that the Visat auto update log will hold the answer to your question, but you need to know when the problem re-occurred.  If you know when the problem re-apperared after you restored the factory image (either because you recorded the date, or can trace the date from emails you sent to Dell), have a look at Control Panel> Windows Update> View Update History.

Chances are that almost every day there'll be things like Windows Defender defintion updates, but these may shouldn't be a problem.  Look for updates for Vista, but in particular driver updates - graphics cards, sound , tuners and the like.  If it is clearly a single particular update, you can uninstall it - but you might need to do thiss for three or four items to track it down.

As an alternative, do a further image restore, and then keep a log of exactly what is installed on the machine, and what is updated, until the problem re-occurs.  If your record keeping is good enough, you should instantly know what the problem is.  Bear in mind that some applications hide services that do auto-updates outside the Vista update control panel - Roxio, and third party antivirus are the sort of thing I have in mind.  Use Msconfig to remove all undesired start up services after doing the image restore in the hope of minimising this sort of issue, although I wouldn't interfere with anti-virus software.

Have you checked the assignment of the Power Management buttons in Control Panel?  It is possible that these have been unintentionally changed during an auto-update?

Regards,

Led

3 Posts

February 9th, 2008 15:00

Thank you, your clue was so helpful, drives me to the problem and could solve it!!!!

The problem seems to come from a wireless ethernet board from Ralink, the only update made other than defender and office's close at that date. Just uninstall it and could powerdown the computer. After, the driver downloaded directly from the manufacturer solve the problem, which by the way is completly different from Vista's. The only question remains to me is the fact that the date when the problem showed and the fail driver's update doesn't match for four days, but anyway now I'm happy.

What are your recomendations for the future? should I trust new updates from Vista?

Thanks a lot!!

137 Posts

February 10th, 2008 08:00

Thank you, pleased to assist!

At first thought, a four day lag between the driver download and the problem doesn't worry me much - drivers are peculiar bits of software, and it may be that the problem only occurs under certain circumstances that didn't immediately trigger - possibly because you'd become accustomed to shutting down via the power button, or simply because your pattern of usage over those few days was slightly different to the norm.

My guess is that the driver problem was caused by some hardware mis-identification by Vista, and it downloaded and installed an incompatible update intended for another product, or possible somebody has mislabelled (for example) an XP-only driver as Vista compatible, and it has then got into the auto update system.

As a broad rule I'd recommend that you should rely on auto-update - it works well 99.999% of the time, and the main things that updates are for is to fix security or stability problems.  Obviously you are now aware of the risk that an auto update can cause problems, but you run similar risks manually updating your machine, with the added inconvenience that brings.  Because most drivers aren't updated regularly, merely when some critical fault is found, I wouldn't expect to see a faulty driver re-install itself, but you'll know what to do if the problem does recur.  You could set auto update to "let me check before install", but that is probably more hassle than it is worth if you have to wade through all the Windows Defender updates (and how would you know which Vista updates you wanted, without reading the knowledge base articles for each one?).  A halfway house if you're feeling a bit concerned would be to deselect the option for "include recommended when checking for updates", because I think (unproven) that will exclude driver updates which are usually shown as "optional" - and you can always check every couple of  months to see if the accumulated optional updates are things you want to risk.  

Incidentally, can you recall if the problem driver update was optional?  If it was, chances are that you may have happily selected the driver update because Vista offered it to you?  The lesson there is not to avoid such actions, just to be aware of the possibility that problems might occur.  The system isn't infallible - I've got an optional Nvidia driver update that I'm not installing, because it is older than the manually installed version on my machine, but equally the driver updates for my TV tuner have all gone on, and caused no problems.

Incidentally, my settings for auto update are to allow it to do everything it can - it checks every day, installs new updates automatically, and includes recommended updates when checking.  This might cause a problem in future, but I'd rather be running take that small risk, but in the meanwhile be happy that I'm running a fully patched system. 

Regards,

Led

1.1K Posts

February 10th, 2008 11:00

Just a quick follow up to what Ledswinger said...he is absolutely correct when he he mentions about optional updates and such.

On my E1705 I had an optional update for my Go 7900 GS, so I checked the dates and such and this update (drivers) was later than the drivers i had on my system, so I gave it a go adn it actually improved my system.  Had the drivers been earlier than what I showed, then I would have just hidden the update so I wouldn't see it again.   So on optional updates just right click on the update, read details, if you don't need it than just click hide update and it won't show up again.

It's always better to update than not.  And it's just a matter of knowing that problems can occur.

Oh yeah, are you going to take back what you said about VISTA????  :smileyvery-happy:

3 Posts

February 10th, 2008 13:00

Regarding what I said to Vista I still think the same. I have Vista in my computer because I had no choice from DELL when I buy this computer, but I was confindent with DELL and give an opportunity to Vista. Now, I have three computers; two of them with VISTA and the other with XP, so I'm able to say I have experience with Vista and I don't like it for a lot of reasons that could fill another thread.

That makes me very suspicious with the new OS so one of the first thing I made was to set the "let me check before install", as Led recommends, to know what's happening behind. I saw the driver update discussed here, but the system works fine that time, as said the system failed 4 days after the driver update(another negative point for Vista).

Maybe I'm on 0.0001%.

You love DELL and I agree, but do you really love Vista??

1.1K Posts

February 10th, 2008 13:00

Do I really love VISTA?  Actually, I do.

I use XP at work and VISTA at home and when I troubleshoot the problems of co-workers that use XP, I tell them CLICK HERE and do this....they say, "I don't have that option."  I say, "Oh, yeah...then go here, here, here and here, then you'll see what I am talking about." 

For me, anyway, VISTA just seems easier, smoother, fewer problems, just overall a better OS.  But that's because I haven't had bad luck.  Games, peripherals, programs, everything works.

When I had XP I had my Windows UPdate that unregistered itself and I had to keep registering it to get it to work.  My games that i used on 95 wouldn't work on XP, so I had more compatibility issues going to XP than I do VISTA. 

But think of it this way....both are decent if you like them, and both stink if you don't.  That's the way it is.

0 events found

No Events found!

Top