Hi everyone,

I am setting up a Dell EMC PowerEdge R740 with Proxmox VE 8. I have run into a specific networking wall that I can't seem to break, and I'm looking for a "final check" before I swap out hardware.

The Situation:

Success: I can install and run Proxmox perfectly if I use a USB-to-RJ45 adapter. The system installs, boots, and gets internet access without issue via the USB adapter.
Failure: The moment I try to use the onboard Broadcom BCM5720 Quad-Port NDC, I get nothing.
- The ports are physically alive: The link lights (heartbeat) are blinking on the server backplane when cables are plugged in.
- Proxmox is blind: The OS simply does not pass traffic or seemingly initialize these ports correctly, even though the hardware lights are active.

The Hardware:

Server: Dell PowerEdge R740
Problematic NDC: Broadcom BCM5720 Quad-Port 1GbE (DP/N: 0FM487)
OS: Proxmox VE 8 (Debian 12 Bookworm)

What I have already tried (using the USB adapter to download packages): I assumed this was a missing driver issue, so I have already done the following:

Drivers/Firmware: Enabled non-free-firmware repos and installed firmware-misc-nonfree (for the tg3 driver), firmware-bnx2, and firmware-bnx2x.
Updates: Ran update-initramfs -u and rebooted multiple times.
Network Config: Verified ip link to see if interfaces were just renamed (e.g., eno1 vs ens2f0)—I updated /etc/network/interfaces to match whatever appeared, but they remain DOWN or NO-CARRIER.
Dell Lifecycle Controller: Updated the NDC firmware to the latest version provided by Dell.
BIOS Settings: Ensured "Integrated Devices" is Enabled, checked IOMMU settings, and verified the card is physically seated correctly.

My Conclusion & Question: Since the server works fine via USB, I know the motherboard/CPU/Proxmox install is healthy. The issue is strictly this Broadcom NDC refusing to play nice with Proxmox VE 8.

I am planning to simply buy an Intel I350-t4 or Intel X550 NDC to replace this Broadcom card.

Is this Broadcom BCM5720 known to be incompatible or "broken" on Proxmox 8?
Is there one final "magic" fix I missed (maybe a specific GRUB parameter or Blacklist)?
Has anyone successfully swapped this specific Broadcom card for an Intel one on an R740 and had it work plug-and-play?

Thanks for any advice!

Pinned Posts

IDRAC 2.70.70.70

Rack Servers

R640 NVME Issues

Old faulty R310 server

Dell PowerEdge R440 Backplane Fire

Help! DELL R770 - Unable to start iDRAC or BMC because of an internal issue - 001. See the message: RAC0185

Dell PowerEdge R730XD + NVIDIA Tesla P100 (PCIe) power cabling behavior

r720 Fan 4 still running after shutdown

Dell dss 2500 power pinouts

R730 new TPM module install causes POST failure

EoL and EOS R630

Dell R740 Network Failure. Broadcom NDC ports blink but won't connect in Proxmox

Issue with upgrade IDRAC9 Enterprise 16 licence

R620 GPU Support Discussion

iDRAC7 initializing failed.

Unable to Format Rack Server – PowerEdge R740

[SOS] R740 3x GPU Upgrade: Need Part Validation Before Purchase – Thanks for Your Help!

Latest Solutions

48GB RAM

PowerEdge XR5610

Dell R640 won't POST, no VIDEO

Secure Boot Error After NIC Firmware Upgrade

Impact of operating servers above the recommended temperature

Dell Support Resources